TOEFL Academic Discussion Writing Sample: nstructions Your professor is teaching a class on human resource management. Write a post responding to the professor's question.
真實考生作答範例,搭配 AI 評分與回饋
目前有 1 篇考生投稿範例
開始免費練習題型概述
Professor
In our discussion on the importance of workplace mentoring, we learned that mentoring (training or guiding someone) is typically associated with senior employees--that is, workers who have been at a company for a long time and mentor younger colleagues. However, at some companies, especially those that use innovative technology, younger employees sometimes train or guide senior colleagues. Do you think that it is a good idea for companies to encourage younger employees to mentor senior coworkers? Why or why not?
Claire
I support the idea of having younger employees mentor senior ones. Technology is developing so rapidly these days, and young people are much more skilled in dealing with technology than older employees are. It's the ideal way for senior employees to learn new digital skills.
Kelly
Claire makes a good point, but technology aside, I do not think that younger employees make good mentors right away. When younger employees join companies, they often lack the experience needed to be fully effective in their roles. They should be mentored by senior coworkers who have achieved a high level of expertise in their work.
考生範例與評分結果
將開啟 LingoLeap App 的寫作題目列表,而非本題。練習需要免費帳號。AI 評分會消耗積分,但 Practice Test 1(PQ26-1)中的題目每天可免費評分 3 次。
1考生範例 #1
I totally believe with Claire that young people mentorting the senior colleague is
benefit with company.Becasuse in this way, the company can keep in ...
分數22
考生範例 #1
I totally believe with Claire that young people mentorting the senior colleague is benefit with company.Becasuse in this way, the company can keep in ...
考生範例
I totally believe with Claire that young people mentorting the senior colleague is benefit with company.Becasuse in this way, the company can keep in a avtive atmosphere and the employees also can work actively. For example, I am working in a company which the essential work is creating the post for software application.It really requires the innovative considerations.In the begining of this year, we work were determined by the senior colleagues but consequntely, their ideas were always outmoded so that our clients often complained about that.Oppositely, now we younger people make the decision about what kind of post is suit for what type of customers. Eventually, we make more profits by this method.Moreover, our company also stay in a active ambidience. Still, I cast doubt with Kelly's idea that in the innovative company, the young people are often can trace the rapidly changing world, so they might have more experiences with the work
評分結果
1. 子项得分
-
Relevance and Contribution to Discussion: 4.0
-
Clarity and Elaboration of Viewpoint: 3.5
-
Language Use and Grammar: 3.0
2. 预估分数
22. 3 任务完成度
这篇文章在回答问题方面做得不错,但还有一些需要改进的地方。首先,你需要更清晰地表达你的观点,并给出更具体的例子来支持你的看法。此外,尽量避免使用过于口语化的表达,以提高文章的正式程度。最后,请注意检查语法错误和词汇用法。
示例1: 原文:I totally believe with Claire that young people mentorting the senior colleague is benefit with company. 修改:I completely agree with Claire that having young people mentor senior colleagues can be beneficial for the company.
示例2: 原文:Moreover, our company also stay in a active ambidience. 修改:Moreover, this approach has created a more dynamic atmosphere within our company.
4. 文章结构与组织
文章结构方面还有待加强。首先,应该有一个简短的引言来引出主题和你的观点。然后,在正文部分详细阐述你的观点,并使用恰当的过渡词来连接各个段落。最后,以一个总结性段落结束全文。
示例1: 添加引言:In response to the professor's question about whether younger employees should mentor senior coworkers, I would like to express my agreement with Claire's viewpoint for the following reasons.
示例2: 过渡词使用:On the one hand, young employees can bring innovative ideas to the company. On the other hand, senior colleagues can still benefit from their experience and expertise in other areas.
5. 语法批改
I totally believe with Claire that young people mentortingmentoring(misspelling) the senior colleague is
benefit with company.Becasuse Becasuse(Missing space between sentences) in this way, the company can keep in aan(Use of 'a' vs. 'an') avtiveactive(misspelling)
atmosphere and the employees also can work actively. For example, I am working in a
company which the essential work is creating the post for software application.It It(Missing space between sentences) really
requires the innovative considerations.In In(Missing space between sentences) the beginingbeginning(misspelling) of this year, we work were
determined by the senior colleagues but consequntelyconsequently(misspelling), their ideas were always
outmoded so that our clients often complained about that.Oppositely Oppositely(Missing space between sentences), now we younger
people make the decision about what kind of post is suit for what type of
customers. Eventually, we make more profits by this method.Moreover Moreover(Missing space between sentences), our company
also staystays(punctuation + singular noun + plural verb) in aan(Use of 'a' vs. 'an') active ambidienceambience(misspelling).
Still, I cast doubt with Kelly's idea that in the innovative company, the young people are
often can trace the rapidly changing world, so they might have more experiences with the
work
Title: 6 文章修订
I concur with Claire's assertion that younger employees mentoring senior colleagues can be advantageous for companies. By fostering such a dynamic, organizations can maintain an energetic atmosphere and promote proactive engagement among employees. For instance, my current workplace primarily focuses on developing content for software applications, which necessitates innovative thinking. Initially, our projects were overseen by senior colleagues; however, their outdated ideas often led to client dissatisfaction. In contrast, when younger employees began making decisions regarding suitable content for various clients, our company experienced increased profits and cultivated a more vibrant environment.
Nevertheless, I question Kelly's perspective that young individuals may lack the necessary experience to excel in innovative companies. In today's rapidly evolving world, younger employees are often better equipped to adapt and stay current with emerging trends and technologies. Consequently, they may possess more relevant experience in certain aspects of their work than their senior counterparts. (151 words)
I totally believe concur with Claire Claire's assertion (revised for clarity and formality) that younger employees mentoring senior colleagues can be advantageous (revised for clarity) for companies. By fostering such a dynamic (revised for coherence), organizations can maintain an energetic atmosphere and promote proactive engagement among employees. For instance, my current workplace primarily focuses on developing content for software applications, which necessitates innovative thinking. Initially, our projects were overseen by senior colleagues; however, their outdated ideas often led to client dissatisfaction. In contrast, when younger employees began making decisions regarding suitable content for various clients, our company experienced increased profits and cultivated a more vibrant environment (revised for coherence).
Nevertheless, I question Kelly's perspective (revised for clarity) that young people mentorting individuals may lack the necessary experience to excel in innovative companies. In today's rapidly evolving world, younger employees are often better equipped to adapt and stay current with emerging trends and technologies. Consequently, they may possess more relevant experience in certain aspects of their work than their senior colleague is ¶ benefit with company.Becasuse in this way, the company can keep in a avtive ¶ atmosphere and the employees also can work actively. For example, I am working in a ¶ company which the essential work is creating the post counterparts (revised for software application.It really ¶ requires the innovative considerations.In the begining of this year, we work were ¶ determined by the senior colleagues but consequntely, their ideas were always ¶ outmoded so that our clients often complained about that.Oppositely, now we younger ¶ people make the decision about what kind of post is suit for what type of ¶ customers. Eventually, we make more profits by this method.Moreover, our company ¶ also stay in a active ambidience. ¶ Still, I cast doubt with Kelly's idea that in the innovative company, the young people are ¶ often can trace the rapidly changing world, so they might have more experiences with the ¶ workcoherence).
Title: 8 思维导图
1. Introduction
- Agree with Claire's assertion
- Younger employees mentoring senior colleagues
- Advantages for companies
2. Maintaining an energetic atmosphere
- Promote proactive engagement among employees
- Example: content development for software applications
3. Outdated ideas from senior colleagues
- Client dissatisfaction
4. Younger employees making decisions
- Increased profits
- Vibrant environment
5. Questioning Kelly's perspective
- Lack of experience in innovative companies
6. Rapidly evolving world
- Younger employees better equipped to adapt and stay current
7. Relevant experience in certain aspects of work
- More than senior counterparts
8. Conclusion
Title: 9 关键词
| Word | Phonetic Symbol | Part of Speech | English Definition | Simplified Chinese Translation | Sample Sentence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| concur | /kənˈkɜr/ | verb | agree | 同意 | I concur with Claire's assertion that younger employees can mentor senior colleagues. |
| dynamic | /daɪˈnæmɪk/ | adjective | characterized by constant change or activity | 动态的 | Fostering such a dynamic can maintain an energetic atmosphere in the company. |
| proactive | /proʊˈæktɪv/ | adjective | taking action to control a situation | 积极主动的 | The company promotes proactive engagement among employees. |
| outdated | /aʊtˈdeɪtɪd/ | adjective | _no longer useful or acceptable | 过时的 | Their outdated ideas often led to client dissatisfaction. |
| innovative | /ˈɪnəˌveɪtɪv/ | adjective | _introducing new ideas or methods | 创新的 | Younger employees excel in innovative companies. |
| evolving | /ɪˈvɒlvɪŋ/ | adjective | gradually developing | 不断发展的 | In today's rapidly evolving world, younger employees are better equipped to adapt. |
| counterparts | /ˈkaʊntərˌpɑrts/ | noun | a person or thing that has the same function as another | 对应物 | They may possess more relevant experience than their senior counterparts. |
| vibrant | /ˈvaɪbrənt/ | adjective | _full of energy and enthusiasm | 充满活力的 | The company cultivated a more vibrant environment. |
| perspective | /pərˈspɛktɪv/ | noun | _a particular way of considering something | 观点 | I question Kelly's perspective on young individuals' experience. |
| adapt | /əˈdæpt/ | verb | to adjust oneself to different conditions | 适应 | Younger employees are better equipped to adapt and stay current with emerging trends. |
將開啟 LingoLeap App 的寫作題目列表,而非本題。練習需要免費帳號。AI 評分會消耗積分,但 Practice Test 1(PQ26-1)中的題目每天可免費評分 3 次。
學術討論如何評分
TOEFL學術討論題型依據官方 ETS 評分標準進行評分,AI 評分系統會從多個面向分析每篇回答。
切題度與貢獻度
回答是否切合題目,並對討論做出有意義的貢獻?
語言運用
文法準確度、詞彙廣度,以及句子結構的品質。
論述發展與支持
論點是否透過具體例子和清楚的推理獲得充分發展?
回答中的常見模式
根據對本題考生投稿的分析,以下是考生回答中常見的模式。
許多考生提出了明確的觀點,卻缺乏具體的佐證例子。
高分回答通常會直接引用閱讀文章內容,並回應其他發言者的觀點。
得分較高的回答會運用多樣的句型結構與學術詞彙。
時間管理是關鍵因素——顯得倉促完成的回答,在論述發展方面通常得分較低。
學習訣竅
動筆前仔細閱讀題目,確認問題的每個部分都已理解。
在回答中引用閱讀文章內容,並回應其他考生的觀點。
用具體例子支持你的主要論點——避免空泛籠統的說法。
字數以 120-150 字為目標。篇幅較長不代表較好,清晰與聚焦更為重要。
練習限時作答(10 分鐘),培養在考試情境下的流暢度。
常見問題
什麼是TOEFL學術討論任務?
學術討論任務如何評分?
此頁面上的用戶範例是什麼?
AI評估的準確度如何?
我要如何練習這道學術討論題目?
我的學術討論回答應該多長?
相關 TOEFL 學術討論題目
All TOEFL Writing Samples
Browse all user-submitted TOEFL writing samples with AI evaluation
TOEFL Academic Discussion Guide
Learn strategies and tips for the Academic Discussion writing task
TOEFL Writing Guide
Complete guide to all TOEFL writing task types and scoring
TOEFL Speaking Guide
Master all TOEFL speaking tasks with expert strategies
TOEFL Reading Guide
Strategies for TOEFL reading comprehension tasks
TOEFL Listening Guide
Tips and practice for TOEFL listening comprehension