TOEFL Academic Discussion Writing Sample: Your professor is teaching a class on education reform.Write a post responding to the professor's question.
真實考生作答範例,搭配 AI 評分與回饋
目前有 1 篇考生投稿範例
開始免費練習題型概述
Professor
This week,we'll examine issues in education reform.For example,some educators think that by focusing mainly on foundational knowledge in subjects like reading, math, and science, schools are not fully preparing students for success in the workplace. These educators argue that soft skills-non-academic skills such as being empathetic or having a strong ability.
Student A
While students need a strong foundation in academic subjects,soft skills are important because they affect well students do their work.If classroom time is set as for these skills,students will take them seriously and academic work will benefit.Teachers could design less so that students learn about a skill and then do role-playing activities with classmates.
Student B
Soft skills are important,but I don't agree with using classroom time to work on them.I'm not sure how teachers would measure students' progress in develop these skills.If students' progress can't be measured or something being taught,I'm not sure if there's any teaching it.
考生範例與評分結果
1考生範例 #1
Recently, the question of whether schools should include soft skills like being empathetic or having a strong work ethic in their curriculum have been...
分數26
考生範例 #1
Recently, the question of whether schools should include soft skills like being empathetic or having a strong work ethic in their curriculum have been...
考生範例
Recently, the question of whether schools should include soft skills like being empathetic or having a strong work ethic in their curriculum have been disputed by educators. Andrew argues that since there is no clear method of measuring student's progress on the soft-skills, so learning it using classroom time does not worth it. However, the essence of these soft skills should not be measured, it is not the subjects in school such as mathematic and English that requires the strong level of comprehension in the future, soft-skills only requires students to master it. Just like Claire suggested, learning soft-skills can consolidate student's mind of study, because they will understand the the importance of academic skills after they learn it. In addition student will make progress on their academic work faster because they will know how to collaborate and communicate with their classmate in order to help themselves.
評分結果
1. 子项得分
Relevance and Contribution to Discussion: 4.5 Clarity and Elaboration of Viewpoint: 4.0 Language Use and Grammar: 4.0
2. 预估分数
26. 3 任务完成度
整体来说,你的文章回应了教授的问题,并表达了自己的观点。但是,你可以进一步改进以下方面:
-
更具体地说明如何在课堂上教授软技能。
-
使用更多例子来支持你的观点。
例如:
-
在讨论如何在课堂上教授软技能时,可以提到具体的课程设计和活动,如团队合作项目或沟通技巧练习。
-
使用实际案例来说明学生在掌握软技能后如何在学术和职业生涯中取得成功。
4. 文章结构与组织
你的文章结构基本清晰,包括引言、正文和结论。然而,在组织方面还有改进空间:
-
在引言部分明确提出自己的观点。
-
在正文部分使用更清晰的过渡词或短语来连接不同段落和观点。
例如:
-
引言部分可以这样写:“在这个关于教育改革的讨论中,我认为学校应该将软技能纳入课程,因为这将有助于学生在学术和职业生涯中取得成功。”
-
在正文部分,可以使用过渡词如“首先”、“其次”或“此外”来引导不同段落和观点。
5. 语法批改
Recently, the question of whetherwhether(the question whether (whether) etc.) schools should include soft skills like being empathetic or having a strong work ethic in their curriculum have been disputed by educators. Andrew argues that since there is no clear method of measuring student's progress on the soft-skills, so learning it using classroom time does not worth it. However, the essence of these soft skills should not be measured, it is not the subjects in school such as mathematic and English that requires the strong level of comprehension in the future, soft-skills only requires students to master it. Just like Claire suggested, learning soft-skills can consolidate student's mind of study, because they will understand the thethe(Word repetition (e.g. 'will will')) importance of academic skills after they learn it. In additionaddition,(Commas after conjunctive/linking adverbs in front of a new sentence.) studentthe student(This rule identifies whether the article 'the' is missing in a sentence.) will make progress on their academic work faster because they will know how to collaborate and communicate with their classmate in order to help themselves.
Display title: 6 文章修订
The debate over whether schools should incorporate soft skills, such as empathy and a strong work ethic, into their curricula has been a contentious issue among educators. Andrew contends that since there is no definitive method for measuring students' progress in soft skills, allocating classroom time for them may not be worthwhile. However, the value of these soft skills should not be underestimated. Unlike subjects like mathematics and English that necessitate a high level of comprehension, mastering soft skills can enhance students' overall learning experience. As Claire suggests, acquiring soft skills can reinforce students' understanding of the importance of academic abilities. Furthermore, students may make more rapid progress in their academic work as they learn to collaborate and communicate effectively with classmates, ultimately benefiting themselves. (129 words)
Recently, the question of Revised essay: Display title: 6 文章修订
The debate over whether schools should include soft skills like being empathetic or having incorporate soft skills, such as empathy and a strong work ethic in ethic, into their curriculum have curricula has been disputed by educators. a contentious issue among educators (rephrased for clarity and conciseness). Andrew argues contends that since there is no clear definitive method of for measuring student's students' progress on the soft-skills, so learning in soft skills (removed the apostrophe from "student's" to make it using plural), allocating classroom time does for them may not worth it. be worthwhile (rephrased for better flow). However, the essence value of these soft skills should not be measured, it is not the underestimated (rephrased for clarity). Unlike subjects in school such as mathematic like mathematics and English that requires the strong necessitate a high level of comprehension (rephrased for better flow), mastering soft skills can enhance students' overall learning experience (rephrased to emphasize the benefits of soft skills). As Claire suggests, acquiring soft skills can reinforce students' understanding of the importance of academic abilities (rephrased to clarify Claire's point). Furthermore, students may make more rapid progress in the future, soft-skills only requires students to master it. Just like Claire suggested, learning soft-skills can consolidate student's mind of study, because they will understand the the importance of academic skills after they learn it. In addition student will make progress on their academic work faster because as they will know how learn to collaborate and communicate effectively with their classmate in order to help themselves.classmates, ultimately benefiting themselves (rephrased for better flow and clarity).
8 思维导图
- 标题: 软技能在学校课程中的重要性
- 争论: 是否应该将软技能纳入课程
- 反对: 无法衡量学生在软技能方面的进步
- 支持: 软技能对学生的整体学习经历有积极影响
- 增强学生对学术能力重要性的理解
- 提高学生在团队合作和沟通方面的效率
- 最终使学生受益
9 关键词
| Word | Phonetic Symbol | Part of Speech | English definition | Simplified Chinese translation | Sample sentences |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| contentious | /kənˈtɛnʃəs/ | adjective | causing or likely to cause an argument; controversial. | 有争议的 | The debate over soft skills in schools is a contentious issue. |
| curricula | /kəˈrɪkjʊlə/ | noun | the subjects comprising a course of study in a school or college. | 课程 | Schools should consider incorporating soft skills into their curricula. |
| empathy | /ˈɛmpəθi/ | noun | the ability to understand and share the feelings of another. | 同理心 | Empathy is an essential soft skill that can enhance students' learning experience. |
| work ethic | /wɜrk ˈɛθɪk/ | noun | the principle that hard work is intrinsically virtuous or worthy of reward. | 职业道德 | A strong work ethic is a valuable soft skill that can benefit students in their future careers. |
| comprehension | /ˌkɒmprɪˈhɛnʃən/ | noun | the action or capability of understanding something. | 理解 | Unlike subjects that require a high level of comprehension, soft skills can be more easily acquired. |
| reinforce | /ˌriːɪnˈfɔrs/ | verb | strengthen or support (an object or substance), especially with additional material. | 加强 | Acquiring soft skills can reinforce students' understanding of the importance of academic abilities. |
| collaborate | /kəˈlabəreɪt/ | verb | work jointly on an activity, especially to produce or create something. | 合作 | Students who learn to collaborate effectively with classmates may make more rapid progress in their academic work. |
| communicate | /kəˈmjuːnɪkeɪt/ | verb | share information, news, ideas, etc., with someone. | 沟通 | Good communication skills are essential for students to succeed in their academic and professional lives. |
6 文章修订
The debate over whether schools should incorporate soft skills, such as empathy and a strong work ethic, into their curricula has been a contentious issue among educators. Andrew contends that since there is no definitive method for measuring students' progress in soft skills, allocating classroom time for them may not be worthwhile. However, the value of these soft skills should not be underestimated. Unlike subjects like mathematics and English that necessitate a high level of comprehension, mastering soft skills can enhance students' overall learning experience. As Claire suggests, acquiring soft skills can reinforce students' understanding of the importance of academic abilities. Furthermore, students may make more rapid progress in their academic work as they learn to collaborate and communicate effectively with classmates, ultimately benefiting themselves.
學術討論如何評分
TOEFL學術討論題型依據官方 ETS 評分標準進行評分,AI 評分系統會從多個面向分析每篇回答。
切題度與貢獻度
回答是否切合題目,並對討論做出有意義的貢獻?
語言運用
文法準確度、詞彙廣度,以及句子結構的品質。
論述發展與支持
論點是否透過具體例子和清楚的推理獲得充分發展?
回答中的常見模式
根據對本題考生投稿的分析,以下是考生回答中常見的模式。
許多考生提出了明確的觀點,卻缺乏具體的佐證例子。
高分回答通常會直接引用閱讀文章內容,並回應其他發言者的觀點。
得分較高的回答會運用多樣的句型結構與學術詞彙。
時間管理是關鍵因素——顯得倉促完成的回答,在論述發展方面通常得分較低。
學習訣竅
動筆前仔細閱讀題目,確認問題的每個部分都已理解。
在回答中引用閱讀文章內容,並回應其他考生的觀點。
用具體例子支持你的主要論點——避免空泛籠統的說法。
字數以 120-150 字為目標。篇幅較長不代表較好,清晰與聚焦更為重要。
練習限時作答(10 分鐘),培養在考試情境下的流暢度。
常見問題
什麼是TOEFL學術討論任務?
學術討論任務如何評分?
此頁面上的用戶範例是什麼?
AI評估的準確度如何?
我要如何練習這道學術討論題目?
我的學術討論回答應該多長?
相關 TOEFL 學術討論題目
All TOEFL Writing Samples
Browse all user-submitted TOEFL writing samples with AI evaluation
TOEFL Academic Discussion Guide
Learn strategies and tips for the Academic Discussion writing task
TOEFL Writing Guide
Complete guide to all TOEFL writing task types and scoring
TOEFL Speaking Guide
Master all TOEFL speaking tasks with expert strategies
TOEFL Reading Guide
Strategies for TOEFL reading comprehension tasks
TOEFL Listening Guide
Tips and practice for TOEFL listening comprehension