TOEFL Academic Discussion Writing Sample: Do you agree or disagree that teachers deserve salaries on par with these professions?Please explain your viewpoint
真實考生作答範例,搭配 AI 評分與回饋
目前有 1 篇考生投稿範例
開始免費練習題型概述
Professor
Doctor Achebe: As teachers play an invaluable role in shaping young minds and preparing students for the future, there is an ongoing discussion regarding their compensation. Some argue that teachers should be paid salaries comparable to other high-earning professionals like doctors, lawyers and business executives. Do you agree or disagree that teachers deserve salaries on par with these professions? Please explain your viewpoint.
Student A
Claire Teachers should receive salaries on par with other high-earning professionals. They work long hours preparing lessons, grading assignments, and supporting students. Without good teachers, we wouldn't have doctors, lawyers, and executives. If we want to attract the best talent to this invaluable profession, we must compensate teachers accordingly. My favorite teachers inspired me and contributed greatly to my success.
Student B
Andrew I don't think teachers deserve the same high salaries as doctors or lawyers. Teachers get so much time off, with summer vacations and other long breaks. My aunt is a teacher and she's always posting on Facebook about trips she takes or sleeping in during vacations. With all that time off, teachers shouldn't earn salaries on par with year-round demanding professions.
考生範例與評分結果
1考生範例 #1
As far as I am concerned, I tend to be in favor of the arguments that teachers do not deseve higher salaries.
To start with, as Andrew mentioned, tea...
考生範例 #1
As far as I am concerned, I tend to be in favor of the arguments that teachers do not deseve higher salaries. To start with, as Andrew mentioned, tea...
考生範例
As far as I am concerned, I tend to be in favor of the arguments that teachers do not deseve higher salaries. To start with, as Andrew mentioned, tearchers have much time off. They do not have much workload, and it is easy for them to handle teaching work, which is almost the same experiences they have gone through. My teacher usually go shopping after class, and travel to other countries during summer and winter vacations. Admittedly, teachers can influence the students. However this is the basic work request. Compared with doctors and other professionals, the theacher have shorter training before working, and their work content is easier.
評分結果
1. Sub Scores
-
Relevance and Contribution to Discussion: 3.5
-
Clarity and Elaboration of Viewpoint: 2.5
-
Language Use and Grammar: 3.0
2. Estimated Scores
Estimated Score: 20
3. Task completeness
The essay addresses the task, but it could be improved in several ways. The writer's viewpoint is not well-elaborated, and the supporting arguments are weak. To strengthen the essay, the writer should provide more concrete examples and relevant details to support their viewpoint.
Example 1: Instead of saying "teachers have much time off," provide specific data on the average number of hours teachers work per week compared to other professionals.
Example 2: Rather than stating that "their work content is easier," explain why teaching might be considered less demanding or complex than other professions, such as medicine or law.
4. Essay structure and organization
The essay has a basic structure with an introduction, body, and conclusion. However, it lacks clear transitions between ideas and paragraphs. To improve the organization, the writer should use transition words or phrases to connect their thoughts more effectively.
Example 1: Add a transition phrase at the beginning of the second paragraph: "To start with, as Andrew mentioned, teachers have much time off."
Example 2: Use a contrasting transition word in the third paragraph to show a different perspective: "On the other hand, it is true that teachers can influence students."
5. Grammar
As far as I am concerned, I tend to be in favor of the arguments that teachers do not desevedeserve(misspelling) higher salaries.
To start with, as Andrew mentioned, tearchersteachers(misspelling) have much time off. They do not have much workload, and it is easy for them to handle teaching work, which is almost the same experiences they have gone through. My teacher usually gogoes(The dog always bark(s) at me) shopping after class, and travel to other countries during summer and winter vacations.
Admittedly, teachers can influence the students. HoweverHowever,(Commas after conjunctive/linking adverbs in front of a new sentence.) this is the basic work request. Compared with doctors and other professionals, the theacherteacher(misspelling) have shorter training before working, and their work content is easier.
Display title: 6 Revised Essay
In my opinion, I disagree with the notion that teachers should receive salaries equivalent to those of high-earning professionals such as doctors and lawyers.
Firstly, as Andrew pointed out, teachers typically enjoy more time off than professionals in other fields. They often have lighter workloads and can easily manage their teaching responsibilities, which are primarily based on their own educational experiences. For instance, my teacher frequently goes shopping after class and travels abroad during summer and winter vacations.
While it is true that teachers can significantly impact their students' lives, this is a fundamental aspect of their job. In comparison to doctors and other professionals who undergo extensive training before entering the workforce, teachers generally have shorter training periods and less demanding work content. (129 words)
As far as In my opinion, I am concerned, I tend to be in favor of disagree with the arguments notion that teachers do not deseve should receive higher salaries. salaries (revised for clarity and to better convey the writer's stance).
To start with, Firstly, as Andrew mentioned, tearchers pointed out, teachers typically enjoy more time off than professionals in other fields (clarified the reference to "Andrew" and improved sentence structure). They often have much time off. They do not have much workload, lighter workloads and it is easy can easily manage their teaching responsibilities, which are primarily based on their own educational experiences (rephrased for them to handle teaching work, which is almost the same experiences they have gone through. My better flow). For instance, my teacher usually go frequently goes shopping after class, class and travel to other countries travels abroad during summer and winter vacations. vacations (corrected grammar).
Admittedly, While it is true that teachers can influence the students. However significantly impact their students' lives, this is the basic work request. Compared with a fundamental aspect of their job (rephrased for clarity). In comparison to doctors and other professionals, professionals who undergo extensive training before entering the theacher workforce, teachers generally have shorter training before working, periods and their less demanding work content is easier.(improved sentence structure and clarity).
Display title: 8 Mind Map
1. Introduction
- Disagree with high salaries for teachers
2. Teachers' time off
- Lighter workloads
- Manageable teaching responsibilities
3. Teaching based on personal experience
- Example: teacher shopping and traveling
4. Impact on students' lives
- Fundamental aspect of job
5. Comparison to other professionals
- Doctors and lawyers' extensive training
- Shorter training periods for teachers
6. Less demanding work content for teachers
7. Conclusion
- Teachers' salaries should not be equivalent to high-earning professionals
Display title: 9 Key Words
| Word | Phonetic Symbol | Part of Speech | English Definition | English Translation | Sample Sentence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Notion | /ˈnoʊʃən/ | Noun | A belief or idea about something | Notion | I disagree with the notion that teachers should receive high salaries. |
| Equivalent | /ɪˈkwɪvələnt/ | Adjective | Equal in value, amount, function, meaning, etc | Equivalent | Teachers should not receive salaries equivalent to those of doctors and lawyers. |
| Workload | /ˈwɜrkˌloʊd/ | Noun | The amount of work assigned to a particular worker | Workload | Teachers typically enjoy lighter workloads than other professionals. |
| Responsibility | /rɪˌspɒnsəˈbɪlɪti/ | Noun | Something that it is your job or duty to deal with | Responsibility | Teaching responsibilities are primarily based on personal experience. |
| Fundamental | /ˌfʌndəˈmɛntl/ | Adjective | Forming a necessary base or core; of central importance | Fundamental | Impacting students' lives is a fundamental aspect of a teacher's job. |
| Workforce | /ˈwɜrkˌfɔrs/ | Noun | The people engaged in or available for work in a country, company, or area | Workforce | Doctors undergo extensive training before entering the workforce. |
| Extensive | /ɪkˈstɛnsɪv/ | Adjective | Large in amount or scale; far-reaching | Extensive | Lawyers have extensive training compared to teachers. |
| Training | /ˈtreɪnɪŋ/ | Noun | The action of teaching a person a particular skill or type of behavior | Training | Teachers generally have shorter training periods than other professionals. |
| Demanding | /dɪˈmændɪŋ/ | Adjective | Requiring much skill or effort; exacting | Demanding | Teaching has less demanding work content compared to other professions. |
Display title: 6 Revised Essay
In my opinion, I disagree with the notion (/ˈnoʊʃən/) that teachers should receive salaries equivalent (/ɪ ˈkwɪvələnt/) to those of high-earning professionals such as doctors and lawyers.
Firstly, as Andrew pointed out, teachers typically enjoy more time off than professionals in other fields. They often have lighter workloads (/ˈwɜrkˌloʊd/) and can easily manage their teaching responsibilities (/rɪˌspɒnsəˈbɪlɪti/), which are primarily based on their own educational experiences. For instance, my teacher frequently goes shopping after class and travels abroad during summer and winter vacations.
While it is true that teachers can significantly impact their students' lives, this is a fundamental (/ˌfʌndəˈmɛntl/) aspect of their job. In comparison to doctors and other professionals who undergo extensive (/ɪkˈstɛnsɪv/) training (/ˈtreɪnɪŋ/) before entering the workforce (/ˈwɜrkˌfɔrs/), teachers generally have shorter training periods and less demanding (/dɪˈmændɪŋ/) work content.
學術討論如何評分
TOEFL學術討論題型依據官方 ETS 評分標準進行評分,AI 評分系統會從多個面向分析每篇回答。
切題度與貢獻度
回答是否切合題目,並對討論做出有意義的貢獻?
語言運用
文法準確度、詞彙廣度,以及句子結構的品質。
論述發展與支持
論點是否透過具體例子和清楚的推理獲得充分發展?
回答中的常見模式
根據對本題考生投稿的分析,以下是考生回答中常見的模式。
許多考生提出了明確的觀點,卻缺乏具體的佐證例子。
高分回答通常會直接引用閱讀文章內容,並回應其他發言者的觀點。
得分較高的回答會運用多樣的句型結構與學術詞彙。
時間管理是關鍵因素——顯得倉促完成的回答,在論述發展方面通常得分較低。
學習訣竅
動筆前仔細閱讀題目,確認問題的每個部分都已理解。
在回答中引用閱讀文章內容,並回應其他考生的觀點。
用具體例子支持你的主要論點——避免空泛籠統的說法。
字數以 120-150 字為目標。篇幅較長不代表較好,清晰與聚焦更為重要。
練習限時作答(10 分鐘),培養在考試情境下的流暢度。
常見問題
什麼是TOEFL學術討論任務?
學術討論任務如何評分?
此頁面上的用戶範例是什麼?
AI評估的準確度如何?
我要如何練習這道學術討論題目?
我的學術討論回答應該多長?
相關 TOEFL 學術討論題目
All TOEFL Writing Samples
Browse all user-submitted TOEFL writing samples with AI evaluation
TOEFL Academic Discussion Guide
Learn strategies and tips for the Academic Discussion writing task
TOEFL Writing Guide
Complete guide to all TOEFL writing task types and scoring
TOEFL Speaking Guide
Master all TOEFL speaking tasks with expert strategies
TOEFL Reading Guide
Strategies for TOEFL reading comprehension tasks
TOEFL Listening Guide
Tips and practice for TOEFL listening comprehension