TOEFL Academic Discussion Writing Sample: Grading Students
Реальные ответы пользователей с оценкой и обратной связью на основе ИИ
Доступно 1 примеров, отправленных пользователями
Начать бесплатную практикуОбзор задания
Professor
Professor: In class today, we are going to talk about grading students. Before you come to class, I want you to think about whether grades are beneficial. On one hand, they provide a way to measure students’ progress. On the other hand, some argue that grades are too focused on performance and don’t provide an accurate picture of a student’s overall academic abilities. If you had to choose, would you say that students should be given grades or not? Why?
Student A
Lila: I think that students should not be given grades. Grades create a needlessly competitive environment and can make students feel like they are only valued for their academic performance. When students feel that grades are the most important thing, they get discouraged. Instead of giving specific grades, teachers should provide personal feedback that helps students understand what they need to improve and how they can do so. I think that approach leads to more academic success.
Student B
Jake: I believe that grades are the only way for students to understand how well they are doing and the only way to motivate them to work harder. Without grades, there would be no way to measure their progress or to identify areas where they need to improve. Moreover, grades prepare students for the real world where they will be judged based on their performance. The only way for adults to advance in their careers is to consistently perform well, and grading children prepares them for that.
Примеры ответов пользователей и результаты оценки
1Пример ответа пользователя #1
From my perspective, students should not be graded. I strongly agree with the Lila’ s idea that giving students grades makes them disappointed and str...
Баллы25
Пример ответа пользователя #1
From my perspective, students should not be graded. I strongly agree with the Lila’ s idea that giving students grades makes them disappointed and str...
Пример ответа пользователя
From my perspective, students should not be graded. I strongly agree with the Lila’ s idea that giving students grades makes them disappointed and stressful. It would be anxious and tiresome for students to focus on their grades and get better grades let them under great pressure. I’ d add that everyone has different capabilities to learn knowledge, pass tests and get good grade. I think that grading students with only academic performance is inequivalent because there are so many characteristics need to be valued when grading a person. Won’t a student’s healthy, integrity, kindness and so on more important than just grades? Jake raised a relevant view that grades bring self-introductions to students and inspire them to enhance, but I think that teacher can also do this out of class. Professors can give specific compliment, suggestions, and encouragement which helps students to perfect.
Результат оценки
1. 子项得分
-
Relevance and Contribution to Discussion: 4.5
-
Clarity and Elaboration of Viewpoint: 4.0
-
Language Use and Grammar: 3.5
2. 预估分数
25. 3 任务完成度
这篇文章在回答问题方面做得不错,你明确表示了支持Lila的观点,并提出了一些有力的论据。但是,为了更好地完成任务,你可以尝试更详细地阐述你的观点,并提供更多具体的例子来支持你的论点。此外,在语法和词汇使用方面还有一些小错误,需要加以改进。
改进建议(英文):
-
Provide more specific examples to support your argument, such as how personal feedback can lead to better academic success compared to grades.
-
Proofread your essay for grammar and vocabulary errors, and try to use a wider range of vocabulary and sentence structures.
4. 文章结构与组织
文章的结构和组织方面还有待提高。虽然你在开头部分简要介绍了自己的观点,但整篇文章缺乏明确的段落划分和逻辑结构。为了使文章更加清晰易懂,请尝试使用恰当的过渡词汇,并确保每个段落都集中讨论一个特定的论点。
改进建议(英文):
-
Divide your essay into clear paragraphs with an introduction, body, and conclusion. For example, start with an introduction that briefly states your viewpoint, followed by body paragraphs that elaborate on your arguments, and finally a conclusion that summarizes your main points.
-
Use appropriate transition words and phrases to connect ideas and paragraphs, such as "firstly," "in addition," "on the other hand," etc. This will help improve the flow and coherence of your essay.
5. 语法批改
From my perspective, students should not be graded. I strongly agree with the Lila’ sLila’s(space after apostrophe in contraction (e.g. I' m)) idea that giving students grades makes them disappointed and stressful. It would be anxious and tiresome for students to focus on their grades and get better grades let them under great pressure. I’ dI’d(space after apostrophe in contraction (e.g. I' m)) add that everyone has different capabilities to learn knowledge, pass tests and get good grade. I think that grading students with only academic performance is inequivalentin equivalent(misspelling) because there are so many characteristics need to be valued when grading a person. Won’t a student’s healthy, integrity, kindness and so on more important than just grades? Jake raised a relevant view that grades bring self-introductions to students and inspire them to enhance, but I think that teacher can also do this out of class. Professors can give specific compliment, suggestions, and encouragement which helps students to perfect.
Grading Students
In my opinion, assigning grades to students is not the most effective approach. I concur with Lila's argument that grades can lead to disappointment and stress among students. The constant pressure to achieve high grades can be mentally exhausting and anxiety-inducing. Furthermore, I believe that evaluating students solely on their academic performance is insufficient, as individuals possess varying abilities to acquire knowledge and excel in examinations. Grading should encompass a more comprehensive assessment of a student's qualities, such as their health, integrity, and kindness – factors that arguably hold greater significance than mere grades. While Jake contends that grades offer students self-awareness and motivation for improvement, I argue that educators can achieve this through alternative means outside the classroom. By providing personalized praise, constructive feedback, and encouragement, teachers can effectively guide students towards growth and success without relying on traditional grading systems. (144 words)
From In my perspective, students should opinion, assigning grades to students is not the most effective approach (revised for clarity and conciseness). I concur with Lila's argument (corrected punctuation) that grades can lead to disappointment and stress among students (rephrased for better flow). The constant pressure to achieve high grades can be graded. mentally exhausting and anxiety-inducing (revised for clarity). Furthermore, I strongly agree with the Lila’ s idea that giving students grades makes them disappointed and stressful. It would be anxious and tiresome for students to focus believe that evaluating students solely on their grades and get better grades let them under great pressure. I’ d add that everyone has different capabilities to learn knowledge, pass tests and get good grade. I think that grading students with only academic performance is inequivalent because there are so many characteristics need to be valued when insufficient (rephrased for better flow), as individuals possess varying abilities to acquire knowledge and excel in examinations (clarified meaning). Grading should encompass a more comprehensive assessment of a student's qualities, such as their health, integrity, and kindness – factors that arguably hold greater significance than mere grades (rephrased for clarity and emphasis). While Jake contends that grades offer students self-awareness and motivation for improvement (clarified meaning), I argue that educators can achieve this through alternative means outside the classroom (rephrased for better flow). By providing personalized praise, constructive feedback, and encouragement, teachers can effectively guide students towards growth and success without relying on traditional grading a person. Won’t a student’s healthy, integrity, kindness and so on more important than just grades? Jake raised a relevant view that grades bring self-introductions to students and inspire them to enhance, but I think that teacher can also do this out of class. Professors can give specific compliment, suggestions, and encouragement which helps students to perfect.systems (revised for clarity and conciseness).
8 思维导图
graph TD
A[Grading Students]
B[Disadvantages of Grades]
C[Alternative Assessment Methods]
D[Varying Abilities to Acquire Knowledge]
E[Comprehensive Assessment Factors]
F[Personalized Praise and Feedback]
G[Motivation for Improvement]
A --> B
A --> C
B --> D
B --> E
C --> F
C --> G
9 关键词
| Word | Phonetic Symbol | Part of Speech | English Definition | Simplified Chinese Translation | Sample Sentence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grading | ˈɡreɪdɪŋ | Noun | The act of assigning a rank or category to something. | 打分 | Assigning grades to students is not the most effective approach. |
| Disappointment | ˌdɪsəˈpɔɪntmənt | Noun | The feeling of sadness or displeasure caused by the nonfulfillment of one's hopes or expectations. | 失望 | Grades can lead to disappointment and stress among students. |
| Anxiety | æŋˈzaɪəti | Noun | A feeling of worry, nervousness, or unease about something with an uncertain outcome. | 焦虑 | The constant pressure to achieve high grades can be anxiety-inducing. |
| Evaluation | / ɪˌvæljuˈeɪʃən/ | / Noun/ | / The making of a judgment about the amount, number, or value of something; assessment./ | / 评估/ | / Evaluating students solely on their academic performance is insufficient./ |
| Integrity | /ɪnˈtɛɡrəti/ | Noun | The quality of being honest and having strong moral principles. | 正直 | Grading should encompass a student's integrity. |
| Kindness | /ˈkaɪndnəs/ | Noun | The quality of being friendly, generous, and considerate. | 善良 | Grading should encompass a student's kindness. |
| Self-awareness | /ˌsɛlf əˈwɛr nəs/ | / Noun/ | / Conscious knowledge of one's own character, feelings, motives, and desires./ | / 自我意识/ | / Grades offer students self-awareness and motivation for improvement./ |
| Praise | / preɪz/ | / Noun/ | / The expression of approval or admiration for someone or something./ | / 赞美/ | / By providing personalized praise, teachers can effectively guide students towards growth and success./ |
| Feedback | / ˈfidbæk/ | / Noun/ | / Information about reactions to a product, a person's performance of a task, etc., used as a basis for improvement./ | / 反馈/ | / Constructive feedback helps students improve their skills and understanding of the subject matter./ |
Как оценивается Academic Discussion
Задание TOEFL Academic Discussion оценивается по официальной шкале ETS. Оценка ИИ анализирует каждый ответ по нескольким параметрам.
Релевантность и вклад
Отвечает ли ответ на вопрос и вносит ли значимый вклад в обсуждение?
Использование языка
Грамматическая точность, разнообразие лексики и качество структуры предложений.
Развитие и аргументация
Хорошо ли раскрыты идеи с помощью конкретных примеров и чёткой аргументации?
Распространённые закономерности в ответах
На основе анализа ответов пользователей по этому заданию — вот распространённые закономерности, замеченные в ответах студентов.
Многие студенты высказывают чёткое мнение, но им не хватает конкретных подтверждающих примеров.
Сильные ответы напрямую ссылаются на текст для чтения и точки зрения других участников.
Ответы с более высокой оценкой используют разнообразные структуры предложений и академическую лексику.
Управление временем — ключевой фактор: ответы, которые выглядят поспешными, обычно получают более низкую оценку за развитие идей.
Советы по обучению
Внимательно прочитайте задание и определите все части вопроса перед тем, как начать писать.
Ссылайтесь в своём ответе на текст для чтения и мнения других студентов.
Используйте конкретные примеры для подтверждения основной мысли — избегайте общих формулировок.
Стремитесь к объёму 120–150 слов. Более длинный ответ не всегда лучше; ясность и фокус важнее.
Тренируйтесь писать ответы на время (10 минут), чтобы выработать беглость в условиях экзамена.
Часто задаваемые вопросы
Что такое задание TOEFL Academic Discussion?
Как оценивается задание Academic Discussion?
Что представляют собой примеры ответов пользователей на этой странице?
Насколько точна оценка на основе ИИ?
Как я могу попрактиковаться в выполнении этого задания Academic Discussion?
Какой длины должен быть мой ответ на Academic Discussion?
Похожие задания TOEFL Academic Discussion
All TOEFL Writing Samples
Browse all user-submitted TOEFL writing samples with AI evaluation
TOEFL Academic Discussion Guide
Learn strategies and tips for the Academic Discussion writing task
TOEFL Writing Guide
Complete guide to all TOEFL writing task types and scoring
TOEFL Speaking Guide
Master all TOEFL speaking tasks with expert strategies
TOEFL Reading Guide
Strategies for TOEFL reading comprehension tasks
TOEFL Listening Guide
Tips and practice for TOEFL listening comprehension
Похожие задания TOEFL Academic Discussion
Consumer Behavior
Доступно 426 примеров, отправленных пользователями
Write A Post Responding To The Professors Question
Доступно 1646 примеров, отправленных пользователями
Economics
Доступно 325 примеров, отправленных пользователями
Academic Discussion
Доступно 1031 примеров, отправленных пользователями
Environmental Science
Доступно 501 примеров, отправленных пользователями
Sociology
Доступно 1683 примеров, отправленных пользователями
Достигните желаемого балла TOEFL уже сегодня!
С LingoLeap — экспертом по подготовке к экзаменам на английском языке
Подготовьтесь к TOEFL быстрее и получите высокий результат