TOEFL Speaking Task 2 Sample: The man expresses his opinion about the proposal described in the letter. Briefly summarize the proposal. Then state his opinion about the proposal and explain the reasons he gives for holding that opinion.

1.子项得分 Delivery: 3 Topic Development: 3 Language Use: 3

2.预估分数

23. 3.表达

从表达方面来看，这位同学的回答基本上是清晰流畅的，语速适中，偶尔有些停顿。为了提高表达能力，建议同学在练习时注意掌握自然的语调和节奏，尽量减少不必要的停顿。同时，注意发音的准确性，以避免拼写错误。

4.话题发展 从话题发展方面来看，这位同学的回答内容基本上是连贯和有条理的，观点之间有明确的联系，并提供了一定的支持或例子。但在阐述观点时可以更加深入和详细。为了提高话题发展能力，建议同学在练习时注意扩展论述内容，给出更多具体的例子和论据来支持自己的观点。

5.语言使用

原文：The student in the letter suggests that the university should require all business majors to complete a summer internship. In the letter, the student suggests that all business majors should be required to complete a summer internship.（将句子的主语和动词更改为更自然的表达方式）（将句子的主语和动词更改为更自然的表达方式） But the man in the listening part doesn't like this idea because, firstly, he says that everyone gets different experiences. However, the man in the conversation disagrees with this idea because he believes that everyone's experiences vary.（使用“however”代替“but”，并使用更高级的词汇“vary”代替“different”）（使用“however”代替“but”，并使用更高级的词汇“vary”代替“different”） For example, his brother did a similar internship previously, and during that time, he always did copy and replied emails every day. For instance, his brother had a similar internship before, and all he did was make copies and respond to emails daily.（使用更自然的表达方式描述兄弟的经历，并使用“daily”代替“every day”）（使用更自然的表达方式描述兄弟的经历，并使用“daily”代替“every day”） So, he didn't get much useful experiences and important skills. As a result, he didn't gain many valuable experiences or essential skills.（使用“as a result”代替“so”，并使用更高级的词汇“valuable”和“essential”）（使用“as a result”代替“so”，并使用更高级的词汇“valuable”和“essential”） Secondly, he thinks that it's difficult for the university to pay students for their internship since the university doesn't have extra money for it. Secondly, he believes that it would be challenging for the university to provide financial support for internships as they lack additional funds.（使用更高级的词汇和表达方式描述观点）（使用更高级的词汇和表达方式描述观点）

修订版（140字）：

In the letter, the student suggests that all business majors should be required to complete a summer internship. However, the man in the conversation disagrees with this idea because he believes that everyone's experiences vary. For instance, his brother had a similar internship before, and all he did was make copies and respond to emails daily. As a result, he didn't gain many valuable experiences or essential skills. Secondly, he believes that it would be challenging for the university to provide financial support for internships as they lack additional funds.

6.思维导图

- Introduction
  - Letter: Require internships

- Man's opinion
  - Disagrees with the proposal
    - Reason 1: Varying experiences
      - Example: Brother's internship
    - Reason 2: Financial challenges
      - University lacks additional funds

7.关键词

1.子项得分

Delivery: 3 Topic Development: 3 Language Use: 3

2.预估分数

23. 3.表达

从表达方面来看，发言者的语言流利度和语速基本一致，偶尔有停顿。为了提高表达能力，建议发言者注意以下几点：1）在适当的地方停顿，以便更清楚地表达思想；2）注意发音的准确性，避免拼写错误；3）在练习时尝试使用更丰富的词汇和表达方式，以增强语言的多样性。

4.话题发展

从话题发展方面来看，发言者的回答内容基本上是连贯和有组织的，思路清晰。但是，在某些地方可以进一步完善。为了提高话题发展能力，建议发言者注意以下几点：1）在总结提案时，尽量简洁明了地概括关键信息；2）在陈述男子的观点时，可以更详细地解释他的理由，并给出具体例子；3）在组织回答时，尝试使用过渡词或短语来连接不同的想法，使回答更加流畅。

5.语言使用

Original Answer: So in the proposal, the author believes that it's a very good idea that the botanical students provide guides for the tourists to fundraise for the generous donor. But in the listening, the man students doesn't think it is a very good idea. Firstly, the information that the students will provide will be very basic. And also the audience cannot really understand the knowledge. And maybe they're keeping saying the same thing to every group and it's very meaningless. And secondly, for the audience, they just want to walk around and see the beautiful flower and enjoy a piece of quiet. And also there are already basic introduction nearby the plants, such as the origin of the plants. So they don't really need this kind of guided service.

Corrected Answer: So in the proposal, the author Natalie Greine believes that it's a very good idea beneficial approach for the botanical students botany students to provide guides for the tourists visitors to fundraise for the generous donor a generous donation. However, in the listening, the man students doesn't think it is a very good idea the male student disagrees with this idea. Firstly, he argues that the information provided by students would be too basic and not truly beneficial for visitors' understanding. Moreover, he believes that guides might end up repeating themselves to different groups, rendering their efforts meaningless. Secondly, he points out that many visitors simply want to stroll around, admire the beautiful flowers, and enjoy some peace and quiet. Furthermore, there are already informative signs near the plants, providing essential details such as their origins. Thus, he concludes that guided tours are not truly necessary.

(将“the author”改为“Natalie Greine”，使回答更具体；将“very good idea”改为“beneficial approach”，提高词汇的多样性；将“the botanical students”改为“botany students”，使表达更准确；将“the tourists”改为“visitors”，使表达更符合语境；将“the generous donor”改为“a generous donation”，使表达更准确；将“the man students doesn't think it is a very good idea”改为“the male student disagrees with this idea”，使语法和表达更准确。)

Revised Answer (140 words): In the proposal, Natalie Greine believes that it's a beneficial approach for botany students to provide guided tours for visitors as a way to fundraise for a generous donation. However, the male student in the listening disagrees with this idea. He argues that the information provided by students would be too basic and not truly beneficial for visitors' understanding. Moreover, he believes that guides might end up repeating themselves to different groups, rendering their efforts meaningless. Secondly, he points out that many visitors simply want to stroll around, admire the beautiful flowers, and enjoy some peace and quiet. Furthermore, there are already informative signs near the plants, providing essential details such as their origins. Thus, he concludes that guided tours are not truly necessary for visitors to have an enjoyable experience at the garden.

6.思维导图

• Proposal

  • Natalie Greine
  • Botany students as guides
  • Fundraise for donation

• Male student's opinion

  • Disagrees with the idea
  • Reasons
    • Basic information provided
    • Repetition for different groups
    • Visitors' preferences (peace and quiet)
    • Existing informative signs

7.关键词

1.Sub Scores Delivery: 3 Topic Development: 3 Language Use: 3

2.Estimated Scores

23. 3.Delivery

The speaker's delivery is generally clear and fluid, but there are occasional pauses that disrupt the flow. To improve, the speaker should practice speaking more consistently and reduce unnecessary pauses. Additionally, pay attention to pronunciation to avoid any spelling errors that may arise from inaccurate pronunciation.

4.Topic Development The response is coherent and well-organized, with clear connections between ideas. However, the speaker could provide more specific examples or details to better support their points. To improve topic development, the speaker should focus on elaborating on their reasons and providing more concrete evidence to strengthen their argument.

5.Language Use

The reading passage proposes that the business department should require all the business major business-major students to complete a summer internship. The man strongly opposes this idea for two main reasons. Firstly, the man believes that not everybody benefits from these internships. For instance, the man's brother did an internship, but he only did 30 works menial tasks("30 works" is unclear; "menial tasks" is more specific and accurate), which demonstrates that there's no guarantee that everybody can gain knowledge from an internship. Secondly, the man believes that it is unrealistic for the university to give money for students to go to internships because the university itself does not have spare money. Overall, the man disagrees with this idea because it is unrealistic and not helpful.

Revised Answer (140 words):

The reading passage suggests that the business department should mandate all business-major students to complete a summer internship. However, the man strongly opposes this proposal due to two primary reasons. First, he argues that not every student will benefit from such internships, as experiences may vary significantly. For example, his brother participated in an internship but only performed menial tasks, indicating that there is no guarantee of gaining valuable knowledge from these experiences. Second, he contends that expecting the university to provide financial assistance for unpaid internships is unrealistic since universities typically do not have extra funds available for such purposes. In conclusion, the man disagrees with the proposal as he believes it is both unrealistic and potentially unhelpful for many students.

6.Mind Map

- Reading Passage
  - Proposal: Require business-major students to complete internships

- Man's Opinion
  - Opposition
    - Reason 1: Varied experiences, not always beneficial
      - Example: Brother's internship with menial tasks
    - Reason 2: Unrealistic financial expectations from the university

- Revised Answer
  - Summary of proposal and man's opinion
  - Elaboration on reasons and examples

7.Key Words

1.子项得分 Delivery: 3 Topic Development: 3 Language Use: 3

2.预估分数

23. 3.表达

从表达方面来看，发言者的语言流利度较好，但仍有一些不必要的停顿。建议发言者在练习口语时注意保持连贯性和一致的语速，尽量减少不必要的停顿。同时，注意发音的准确性，以避免拼写错误。

4.话题发展 从话题发展方面来看，发言者对提案进行了简要概述，并阐述了男生对提案的看法及理由。但在组织结构上可以更加清晰。建议在练习时注意逻辑性和条理性，确保观点之间有明确的联系，并提供足够的支持或例子。

5.语言使用

Original Answer: The writer proposes that the business department should require all the business students to complete a summer internship. Well, in that conversation, the man doesn't agree with her idea, because his brother who once had a summer internship in last summer, but he said all he did is to have had some copies of the paper, so he didn't get anything useful through this experience. And another is that this proposal is not realistic, because considering that the university cannot have extra money to pay for the students, so how can they force doing so without pay?

Corrected Answer: The writer proposes suggests (建议使用suggests，因为它在这种情况下更自然) that the business department should require all the (删除the，因为此处不需要特指) business students to complete a summer internship. Well, (删除Well，因为它在这里不必要) In that conversation, the man doesn't agree with her idea, because his brother who once had had (删除once，因为had已经表示过去的动作) a summer internship in last summer, the previous summer, (用the previous summer替换in last summer，使句子更自然) but he said all he did is to have had was make (用was make替换is to have had，使句子结构更简洁) some copies of the paper, so he didn't get anything useful through from (用from替换through，使句子更自然) this experience. And another is that Furthermore, (用Furthermore替换And another is that，使句子过渡更自然) this proposal is not realistic, because considering that the university cannot have extra money to pay for the students, so how can they force doing so without pay?

Revised Answer (140 words): The writer suggests that the business department should require all business students to complete a summer internship. In the conversation, the man disagrees with her idea, citing his brother's unproductive experience during a summer internship the previous year. He explains that his brother only made copies of documents and did not gain any valuable skills from the experience. Furthermore, the man argues that the proposal is unrealistic, as it assumes that the university can provide financial assistance to students participating in unpaid internships. He questions how the university could enforce such a requirement without offering compensation. Overall, the man believes that mandatory internships may not guarantee beneficial experiences for all students and questions the feasibility of providing financial support for unpaid internships.

6.思维导图

- Proposal
  - Require business students to complete summer internships

- Man's opinion
  - Disagrees with the proposal
  - Reasons
    - Brother's unproductive experience
    - Unrealistic expectations for university financial assistance

- Revised Answer
  - Summary of man's opinion and reasons

7.关键词

1.子项得分 Delivery: 2 Topic Development: 2 Language Use: 2

2.预估分数

17. 3.表达

在回答中，发音和语速需要改进。尝试练习更清晰、流畅的发音，并保持一致的语速。避免在不适当的地方停顿。同时，注意准确发音以避免拼写错误。

4.话题发展 回答内容需要更加连贯和组织良好。在总结提议时，请确保提到关键信息，如实习经历的好处和建议学校提供财务支持。在陈述男子的观点时，请详细说明他的理由，例如实习经历可能并非总是有益的，并且学校可能无法提供财务支持。尝试使用更多例子和细节来支持你的观点。

5.语言使用

原文：In the letter, the student suggests that the university should provide student business internships. In the letter, the student proposes that the business department should require all business majors to complete a summer internship. (原句中的表述不准确，需要明确提到商学院和暑期实习。)

Firstly, the students can learn a lot of important skills. First, students can acquire valuable skills through internships. (修改了句子结构，使其更自然。)

Secondly, students should earn the money, so the university should pay the money for the students. Second, since many internships are unpaid, the university could provide financial assistance for students with unpaid internships. (原句表达不清楚，需要详细说明财务支持的原因。)

The man thinks this is a really terrible idea. The man disagrees with this proposal. (使用更正式的表达方式。)

For example, his brother. His brother worked in a company, but he didn't get anything, and he didn't receive any benefit skills. For instance, his brother had an internship where he only performed menial tasks and did not gain any valuable skills. (重新组织句子，使其更连贯。)

And this is what a lot of students disappoint about, and they think they don't have any useful skills. This is a common disappointment among students who feel they do not gain useful skills from their internships. (修改句子结构，使其更自然。)

Secondly, this policy is not really realistic, because the university don't have extra money, and if they have extra money, they will use the money to another anything. Additionally, the man believes that the policy is unrealistic since the university may not have extra funds to support students financially during their internships. (重新组织句子，使其更清晰。)

Instead of giving the students money, so the man thinks this is a really terrible idea. Therefore, he considers the proposal impractical. (简化句子，使其更自然。)

Revised Answer (140 words):

In the letter, the student proposes that the business department should require all business majors to complete a summer internship. First, students can acquire valuable skills through internships. Second, since many internships are unpaid, the university could provide financial assistance for students with unpaid internships. The man disagrees with this proposal. For instance, his brother had an internship where he only performed menial tasks and did not gain any valuable skills. This is a common disappointment among students who feel they do not gain useful skills from their internships. Additionally, the man believes that the policy is unrealistic since the university may not have extra funds to support students financially during their internships. Therefore, he considers the proposal impractical.

6.思维导图

- Letter
  - Proposal
    - Require summer internships
    - Benefits
      - Valuable skills
    - Financial assistance for unpaid internships

- Man's opinion
  - Disagreement
    - Reasons
      - Inconsistent internship experiences
        - Brother's example: menial tasks, no valuable skills
      - Unrealistic policy
        - University's financial constraints

7.关键词

1.Sub Scores Delivery: 3 Topic Development: 4 Language Use: 3

2.Estimated Scores

26. 3.Delivery

The speaker's delivery is generally clear and fluid, but there are occasional pauses that could be improved. To enhance the delivery, the speaker should practice maintaining a consistent pace throughout the response and work on reducing unnecessary pauses. This will result in a smoother and more natural-sounding speech.

4.Topic Development The topic development in the response is excellent. The speaker provides a coherent and well-organized response, with clear connections between ideas and sufficient support or examples. The summary of the proposal, the man's opinion, and the reasons for his opinion are all clearly presented. No significant improvements are needed in this aspect of the response.

5.Language Use

Original Answer: The reading passage proposes that the literature department should eliminate the requirement for the course Contemporary Literature since it is unnecessary for many students. The reading passage suggests that the literature department should remove the Contemporary Literature course requirement, as it is deemed unnecessary for numerous students. (Rephrased for a more natural-sounding language style)

The man strongly opposes this idea for two main reasons. The man vehemently disagrees with this proposal due to two primary factors. (Used advanced vocabulary and a more natural-sounding language style)

Firstly, he thinks that reading the materials for class is different from reading for leisure. First, he believes that studying class materials significantly differs from leisure reading. (Rephrased for a more natural flow and used advanced vocabulary)

Although many students might have read the books for pleasure, it is different if they read critically in preparation for courses. While numerous students may have read the books for enjoyment, engaging in critical analysis in preparation for classes sets them apart. (Rephrased for a more natural flow and used advanced vocabulary)

In addition, the man thinks that the requirement is manageable and fair since the case where students need to spend more time is rare. Furthermore, the man considers the requirement reasonable and equitable, as instances of students needing additional time are uncommon. (Used advanced vocabulary and a more natural-sounding language style)

Revised Answer (140 words): The reading passage suggests that the literature department should remove the Contemporary Literature course requirement, as it is deemed unnecessary for numerous students. The man vehemently disagrees with this proposal due to two primary factors. First, he believes that studying class materials significantly differs from leisure reading. While numerous students may have read the books for enjoyment, engaging in critical analysis in preparation for classes sets them apart. Furthermore, the man considers the requirement reasonable and equitable, as instances of students needing additional time are uncommon.

6.Mind Map

- Reading Passage
  - Remove Contemporary Literature requirement
  - Unnecessary for numerous students

- Man's Opinion
  - Vehemently disagrees
  - Two primary factors
    - Studying class materials vs. leisure reading
      - Critical analysis in preparation for classes
    - Requirement reasonable and equitable
      - Instances of students needing additional time uncommon

7.Key Words

1.子项得分 Delivery: 3 Topic Development: 3 Language Use: 3

2.预估分数

23. 3.表达

总体来说，发言者的表达较为清晰，但在某些地方存在一些不必要的停顿。为了提高发言的流畅性，建议发言者在练习时注意保持一致的语速，并尽量减少不必要的停顿。此外，发言者需要注意正确发音，以避免拼写错误。

4.话题发展 The speaker provided a coherent response, summarizing the proposal and stating the man's opinion. However, the response could be better organized and more concise in presenting the reasons for the man's opinion. To improve topic development, the speaker should focus on clearly connecting ideas and providing sufficient support or examples from the listening passage. Additionally, it would be helpful to use transition words or phrases to guide the listener through the response more effectively.

5.语言使用

Original Answer: The student in the letter suggests that the university should eliminate contemporary literature requirement for students' graduation. The student in the letter suggests that the university should eliminate the contemporary literature requirement for students' graduation. (添加定冠词 "the" 使句子更自然) But the man in the listening part doesn't like this idea. However, the man in the listening passage disagrees with this idea. (使用 "however" 和 "listening passage" 使句子更自然和准确) Because, firstly, he says that, although this requirement is not necessary, most students don't analyze and critically think when they read contemporary literature books. Firstly, he argues that although this requirement may not be necessary, most students do not analyze and think critically when they read contemporary literature books. (调整句子结构，使其更自然流畅) Therefore, in the class, they will have chance to have a lot of discussions and write paper about contemporary literature, which definitely will help them get different experience and deeper understanding of the lecture topics. Therefore, in class, they will have the opportunity to engage in discussions and write papers about contemporary literature, which will undoubtedly help them gain a diverse experience and a deeper understanding of the lecture topics. (调整句子结构，使其更自然流畅，并使用更高级词汇) Secondly, he thinks that, although some students might stay longer in the university, it's still a rare situation. Secondly, he believes that although some students might stay longer at the university, it is still a rare situation. (使用 "believes" 和 "at the university" 使句子更自然) Because, in... Because, in general... (添加 "in general" 使句子更自然)

Revised Answer (140 words):

The student in the letter suggests that the university should eliminate the contemporary literature requirement for students' graduation. However, the man in the listening passage disagrees with this idea. Firstly, he argues that although this requirement may not be necessary, most students do not analyze and think critically when they read contemporary literature books. Therefore, in class, they will have the opportunity to engage in discussions and write papers about contemporary literature, which will undoubtedly help them gain a diverse experience and a deeper understanding of the lecture topics. Secondly, he believes that although some students might stay longer at the university, it is still a rare situation. Because, in general, what the department asks of literature students is fair and manageable.

6.思维导图

• Introduction

  • Student's proposal: eliminate contemporary literature requirement
  • Man's opinion: disagrees

• Reason 1

  • Students don't analyze and think critically when reading contemporary literature books
  • In-class discussions and papers provide deeper understanding

• Reason 2

  • Staying longer at university is a rare situation
  • Department's requirements are fair and manageable

7.关键词

1.子项得分

• 交付 (Delivery): 3

• 主题发展 (Topic Development): 3

• 语言使用 (Language Use): 3

2.预估分数: 23

3.表达 整体来说，回答的表达较为清晰，但在某些地方存在一些不必要的停顿。为了提高口语表达能力，建议在练习时注意保持连贯流畅的语速，并尽量减少不必要的停顿。同时，注意正确发音以避免拼写错误。

4.话题发展 回答内容基本上符合题目要求，但在论述原因时可以更加具体和详细。例如，在提到学校没有足够的资金提供给实习生时，可以进一步解释这会对学生产生什么样的影响。此外，在总结部分可以更明确地表达出对方案的反对意见。建议在练习时关注提供更多有力的论据和例子来支持观点，并确保回答结构清晰有条理。

5.语言使用

原文：The plan proposed that the students should require business internships. The proposal suggests that students should be required to complete business internships.（建议将“plan”改为“proposal”，以更准确地描述信中的建议。同时，将“should require”改为“should be required to complete”，使句子更自然。） This way, every student could benefit from these sort of experiences, In this manner, all students could benefit from such experiences,（将“this way”改为“in this manner”，使句子更正式。同时，将“these sort of”改为“such”，使句子更自然。） and the school could also provide some financial assistance with the unpaid internships. However, the man does not agree with this statement. It was due to a fact that his brother did a similar thing a while back, and he didn't get much out of it. So there will be no guarantee that these sort of courses or internships will be useful. Besides, it would be unrealistic for a school to provide financial assistance to the unpaid internships. Moreover, expecting the university to provide financial assistance for unpaid internships would be unrealistic.（将“Besides”改为“Moreover”，使句子更正式。同时，调整句子结构以使其更自然。） This is due to a fact that there isn't much money lying around at school, so they don't have a lot of money in order to give to the unpaid internships. Therefore, this plan will not work.

修订版（140字）：

The proposal suggests that students should be required to complete business internships. In this manner, all students could benefit from such experiences, and the school could also provide some financial assistance with the unpaid internships. However, the man does not agree with this statement. It was due to a fact that his brother did a similar thing a while back, and he didn't get much out of it. So there will be no guarantee that such courses or internships will be useful. Moreover, expecting the university to provide financial assistance for unpaid internships would be unrealistic. This is due to a fact that there isn't much money lying around at school, so they don't have a lot of money in order to give to the unpaid internships. Therefore, this plan will not work.

6.思维导图

• Proposal

  • Require business internships
  • Benefits for students
  • Financial assistance for unpaid internships

• Man's opinion

  • Disagreement
  • Brother's experience
  • No guarantee of usefulness
  • Unrealistic expectations for financial assistance

7.关键词

1.子项得分 Delivery: 3 Topic Development: 3 Language Use: 3

2.预估分数

23. 3.表达

从表达方面来看，这位同学的回答相对清晰，但在某些地方可能需要稍作调整以提高流畅度。建议同学注意在适当的地方停顿，以便更好地组织语言。此外，尽量准确发音单词，以避免拼写错误。

4.话题发展 从话题发展方面来看，这位同学的回答基本上是连贯和有组织的，但在某些地方可能需要进一步明确观点和论据。建议同学在回答时更加关注论据的连贯性和逻辑性，并尝试提供更多具体的例子来支持观点。

5.语言使用

Original: The proposal states that students who majored major in literacy already read lots of books in their free time and have many credits than other majors. (建议使用现在时态，因为这是一个普遍现象。) However, the men disagreed with this proposal for two reasons. First, the men suggest that it's true for people read a lot of books outside of the class, but they just read it for fun and in the class they have to do some discussions and prepare papers, which will be more useful for students majored in literacy. Second, he doesn't think it's unreasonable because there are lots of people who just transferred their majors and need to do some more work to catch up with other people, and it's actually practical for them.

Corrected: The proposal states that students who majored major in literacy literature (应该使用“文学”而不是“识字”作为专业名称。) already read lots of books in their free time and have more credits than other majors. However, the man disagreed with this proposal for two reasons. First, he suggests that it's true that people read a lot of books outside of the class, but they just read them for fun, whereas in class they have to engage in discussions and prepare papers, which is more useful for students majoring in literature. Second, he doesn't think it's unreasonable because there are many people who have just transferred their majors and need to do extra work to catch up with others, making it practical for them.

Revised Answer (140 words):

The proposal suggests that students who major in literature already read many books in their free time and have more credits than other majors. However, the man disagrees with this proposal for two reasons. First, he argues that although people read numerous books outside of class, they do so for enjoyment, while in class they must participate in discussions and prepare papers, which is more beneficial for literature students. Secondly, he believes the proposal is not unreasonable because there are a significant number of students who have recently changed their majors and need to complete additional work to catch up with their peers, making the current requirements practical and manageable.

6.思维导图

- Proposal
  - Major in literature
  - Read books in free time
  - More credits than other majors

- Man's disagreement
  - Reason 1: Reading for fun vs. in-class learning
    - Discussions and papers
    - More beneficial for literature students
  - Reason 2: Unreasonable proposal
    - Students who changed majors
    - Additional work to catch up
    - Practical and manageable requirements

7.关键词