TOEFL Academic Discussion Writing Sample: Instructions: Your professor is teaching a class on education. Write a post responding to the professor's question. In your response you should:. express and support your personal opinion.make a contribution to the discussion in your own words An effective response will contain at least 100 words.

1. Sub Scores

• Relevance and Contribution to Discussion: 4.5

• Clarity and Elaboration of Viewpoint: 4.0

• Language Use and Grammar: 4.0

2. Estimated Scores

Estimated Score: 27

3. Task completeness

The essay does a good job of addressing the task requirements, expressing a clear opinion and supporting it with relevant arguments. However, there is room for improvement in terms of elaborating on the viewpoint and providing more specific examples to strengthen the argument.

Suggestions for improvement:

• Provide more concrete examples to support your points.

• Further elaborate on your viewpoint by discussing potential drawbacks or counterarguments.

Examples:

1. "For instance, a student who excels in mathematics might be encouraged by their teacher to pursue a degree in engineering or computer science, as these fields are known for their high demand and lucrative job opportunities."
2. "While some may argue that students should have complete autonomy in choosing their field of study, it is important to consider that guidance from experienced individuals can help them make informed decisions that will benefit them in the long run."

4. Essay structure and organization

The essay has a clear structure with an introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion. The organization is mostly logical, but there is room for improvement in terms of transitions between ideas and paragraphs.

Suggestions for improvement:

• Use clearer transitions between ideas within paragraphs.

• Ensure each paragraph focuses on one main point with supporting details.

Examples:

1. "In addition to considering academic strengths, parents can also provide valuable input based on their understanding of their child's personality traits and preferences."
2. "On the other hand, it is essential not to disregard the importance of personal interests when making such decisions. A balance between guidance from parents and teachers and individual choice should be sought to ensure both success and personal satisfaction."

5. Grammar

While Andrew's viewpoint holds merit, I am inclined to agree with Kelly that parents and teachers' suggestions are crucial factorfactors for secondary school. Building upon Kelly's argument, I would like to emphasize that students in secondary school have high possibilities deciding a wrong path since they are in thea stage of mental immaturity. However, parents and teachers have enoughteachers, with their social experienceexperience, can guide students to choose a right path that benefits their well-being in the future. Besides, they are familiar with the majors and lives in the university.university life. It means they know which major havehas high employment rate,and graduation rate,rates, as well as tell them someinform students of convenient methods to solve somepotential troubles in the campus. Moreover, parents and teachers can give someprovide useful advices for students thatadvice for students that help them avoid students to regretregrets in the future. Teachers alwaysTeachers, who teach and grade students that theystudents, are totally knowaware of which academic area is their good at.strong suit. Teachers can give a reasonable suggestions for students to choose which subject will studentsthey should major in. Also, parents are familiar with your characteristics and living habits. They can help you to choose the university by lookingconsidering the location and university's surrounding environment. By combining parents and teachersteachers' viewpoints, I convinced that you must have a perfect school choice that benefits you forever. In light of these points, Itit is evident that the benefits of parents and teachers advicesteachers' advice for secondary students far outweigh any potential drawbacks.

Display title: 6 Revised Essay

While Andrew's viewpoint holds merit, I am inclined to agree with Kelly that the guidance of parents and teachers is a crucial factor for secondary school students in choosing their field of study.

Building upon Kelly's argument, I would like to emphasize that students in secondary school may have a higher likelihood of making an ill-informed decision due to their mental immaturity. Parents and teachers, with their wealth of social experience, can guide students towards a path that benefits their well-being in the future. Furthermore, they are familiar with university majors and campus life, which means they can provide insights on employment rates, graduation rates, and offer practical advice for navigating campus challenges.

Moreover, parents and teachers can offer valuable advice to help students avoid future regrets. Teachers interact with and evaluate students regularly, giving them insight into each student's strengths and weaknesses in various academic areas. They can provide well-informed suggestions on which subjects would be best suited for each student. Similarly, parents are familiar with their child's characteristics and living habits. They can assist in selecting a university based on factors such as location and the surrounding environment. By combining the perspectives of both parents and teachers, I am convinced that students will make well-rounded choices that benefit them in the long run.

In light of these points, it is evident that the benefits of guidance from parents and teachers for secondary school students far outweigh any potential drawbacks when choosing a field of study at university. (254 words)

While Andrew’s Andrew's viewpoint holds merit, I am inclined to agree with Kelly that parents and teachers’ suggestions are the guidance of parents and teachers is a crucial factor for secondary school. school students in choosing their field of study (revised for clarity and specificity).

Building upon Kelly’s Kelly's argument, I would like to emphasize that students in secondary school may have high possibilities deciding a wrong a higher likelihood of making an ill-informed decision due to their mental immaturity (revised for clarity). Parents and teachers, with their wealth of social experience, can guide students towards a path since they are in the stage of mental immaturity. However, parents and teachers have enough social experience can guide students to choose a right path that benefits their well-being in the future. Besides, Furthermore, they are familiar with the university majors and lives in the university. It campus life, which means they know which major have high can provide insights on employment rate, rates, graduation rate, as well as tell them some convenient methods to solve some troubles in the campus. rates, and offer practical advice for navigating campus challenges (revised for readability).

Moreover, parents and teachers can give some useful advices for students that offer valuable advice to help students avoid students to regret in the future. future regrets (revised for clarity). Teachers always teach and grade students that they are totally know interact with and evaluate students regularly, giving them insight into each student's strengths and weaknesses in various academic areas. They can provide well-informed suggestions on which academic area is their good at. Teachers can give a reasonable suggestions for students to choose which subject will students major in. Also, subjects would be best suited for each student (revised for readability). Similarly, parents are familiar with your their child's characteristics and living habits. They can help you to choose the assist in selecting a university by looking the based on factors such as location and university’s the surrounding environment. environment (revised for clarity). By combining parents and teachers viewpoints, the perspectives of both parents and teachers, I am convinced that you must have a perfect school choice that benefits you forever. students will make well-rounded choices that benefit them in the long run (revised for readability).

In light of these points, It it is evident that the benefits of guidance from parents and teachers advices for secondary school students far outweigh any potential drawbacks.drawbacks when choosing a field of study at university (revised for clarity).

8 Mind Map

1. Introduction

   • Andrew's viewpoint
   • Agree with Kelly
   • Importance of guidance from parents and teachers

2. Mental immaturity of secondary school students

   • Ill-informed decisions
   • Parents and teachers' experience

3. Familiarity with university majors and campus life

   • Employment rates
   • Graduation rates
   • Practical advice

4. Avoiding future regrets

   • Teachers' insight into student strengths and weaknesses
   • Parents' knowledge of child's characteristics and habits

5. Well-rounded choices

   • Combining perspectives of parents and teachers

6. Conclusion

   • Benefits outweigh drawbacks

9 Key Words