TOEFL Academic Discussion Writing Sample: In your opinion, does taking a gap year create more advantages or disadvantages for students? Why?
Real user submissions with AI-powered evaluation and feedback
2 user-submitted samples available
Start Free PracticeTask Overview
Professor
This week. we' ook at how we students transition to university. Many recent high school graduates have taken a gap vear-a vearlong break after graduation - before studying at a university. During a gap year, students may get jobs, travel, or simply relax and think about their future. Some students say their gap year was beneficial, while others regret having taken one. In your opinion, does taking a gap year create more advantages or disadvantages for students? Why?
Andrew
The gap year would be a good opportunity for students to reflect on their education goals and confirm their plans tor university. At least it would give someone time to investigate different fields and get a better sense of what it means to be in business. to work in an ottice. or to work with their hands. etc.
Claire
Because university can be expensive, students should not take a gap year. Tuition, the cost of books, and living expenses rise every year. The money a student might save during a gap year might not be enough to cover the rise in prices when the enter universitv a vear later.
User Samples & Evaluation Results
Opens the writing question list in the LingoLeap app, not this exact question. Practising needs a free account. AI scoring uses credits, except 3 free scores a day on Practice Test 1 (PQ26-1) questions.
1User Sample #1
Claire presents a convincing argument that students should not take a gap year because of the increase in tuition and other costs. Admittedly, the inc...
Score27
User Sample #1
Claire presents a convincing argument that students should not take a gap year because of the increase in tuition and other costs. Admittedly, the inc...
User Sample
Claire presents a convincing argument that students should not take a gap year because of the increase in tuition and other costs. Admittedly, the increasing fees will creat a financial burden for students. However, considering choosing the future field more respondently, I am inclined to support the stand that it is benifit for students to take a gap year. To be more specific, students can experience various lifestyles this year, such as working in the shop, writing in the library, or just cooking at home, making them know what they enjoy and which field they may want to explore. For example, I have taken a gap year to go to a financial company, and I have learned a lot of discipline about how society works and how economics float, which encouraged me to apply economics as my major in the university. Therefore, I firmly believe that students should take a gap year to think about what they want.
Evaluation Result
1. 子项得分
-
Relevance and Contribution to Discussion: 4.5
-
Clarity and Elaboration of Viewpoint: 4.0
-
Language Use and Grammar: 4.0
2. 预估分数
- 27
3. 任务完成度
虽然你的文章回答了问题,但是可以在以下方面进行改进:
-
提供更多具体的例子来支持你的观点。
-
更全面地讨论优点和缺点,以便更好地平衡文章。
例如:
-
在论述为什么学生应该休学一年时,可以提到实际的工作经历或旅行经历如何帮助他们成长和发现自己的兴趣。
-
在讨论不利因素时,可以谈到如何解决财务问题或如何确保在休学期间充分利用时间。
4. 文章结构与组织
文章结构基本清晰,但可以在以下方面进行改进:
-
增加一个引言段落,简要介绍主题和你将要讨论的观点。
-
在正文段落中使用更明确的过渡词汇来连接不同观点。
例如:
-
引言:在高中毕业后,许多学生选择休学一年再继续攻读大学。这一现象引发了关于休学年对学生是否有益的讨论。本文将探讨休学年的优缺点。
-
过渡词汇:首先,休学一年可以帮助学生了解自己的兴趣和目标。其次,尽管财务问题是一个挑战,但通过合理规划和积极应对,学生仍可以从休学年中受益。
5. 语法批改
Claire presents a convincing argument that students should not take a gap year because of the increase in tuition and other costs. Admittedly, the increasing fees will creatgreat(misspelling) a financial burden for students. However, considering choosing the future field more respondentlydespondently(misspelling), I am inclined to support the stand that it is benifitbenefit(misspelling) for students to take a gap year. To be more specific, students can experience various lifestyles this year, such as working in the shop, writing in the library, or just cooking at home, making them know what they enjoy and which field they may want to explore. For example, I have taken a gap year to go to a financial company, and I have learned a lot of discipline about how society works and how economics float, which encouraged me to apply economics as my major in the university. Therefore, I firmly believe that students should take a gap year to think about what they want.
Section Title: 6 Article Revision
While Claire raises a valid concern regarding the financial implications of taking a gap year, I believe that the potential benefits of this experience outweigh the drawbacks. It is true that tuition and living expenses may increase during this time; however, the opportunity for students to gain valuable insights into their future career paths should not be overlooked. By engaging in diverse experiences such as working in retail, conducting research at a library, or even exploring culinary interests at home, students can discover their passions and make more informed decisions about their academic pursuits. For instance, my own gap year experience at a financial firm provided me with invaluable knowledge about economics and societal structures, ultimately inspiring me to major in economics at university. Consequently, I strongly advocate for students to consider taking a gap year as a means of reflecting on their aspirations and making well-rounded choices for their futures. (156 words)
Revised essay: Section Title: 7 Article Revision
While Claire presents a convincing argument that students should not take a gap year because due to the increase in tuition and other costs, I believe that the potential benefits of the this experience outweigh the drawbacks (rephrased for clarity and to maintain original meaning). It is true that tuition and living expenses may increase in tuition and other costs. Admittedly, the increasing fees will creat a financial burden for students. However, considering choosing the during this time; however, the opportunity for students to gain valuable insights into their future field more respondently, I am inclined to support the stand that it is benifit for students to take a gap year. To career paths should not be more specific, students can experience various lifestyles this year, overlooked (added "however" for smoother transition). By engaging in diverse experiences such as working in the shop, writing in the retail (changed "shop" to "retail" for specificity), conducting research at a library, or just cooking even exploring culinary interests at home, making them know what they enjoy and which field they may want to explore. students can discover their passions and make more informed decisions about their academic pursuits (rephrased for clarity). For example, I have taken a instance, my own gap year to go to experience at a financial company, and firm provided me with invaluable knowledge about economics and societal structures (clarified "discipline" as "knowledge"), ultimately inspiring me to major in economics at university. Consequently, I have learned a lot of discipline about how society works and how economics float, which encouraged me to apply economics as my major in the university. Therefore, I firmly believe that students should take strongly advocate for students to consider taking a gap year to think about what they want.as a means of reflecting on their aspirations and making well-rounded choices for their futures (rephrased conclusion for clarity and impact).
8 思维导图
- 主题:间隔年的利弊
- 利
- 发现兴趣和激情
- 做出更明智的职业选择
- 获得宝贵的人生经验
- 弊
- 经济负担
- 学费和生活费增加
9 关键词
| Word | Phonetic Symbol | Part of Speech | English definition | Simplified Chinese translation | Sample sentences |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| gap year | /ɡæp jɪr/ | noun | A year taken by a student as a break between high school and college or university education. | 间隔年 | Taking a gap year can provide students with valuable experiences and insights into their future career paths. |
| implications | /ˌɪmplɪˈkeɪʃənz/ | noun | The possible results or effects of an action or decision. | 后果 | Claire raises a valid concern regarding the financial implications of taking a gap year. |
| drawbacks | /ˈdrɔːbæk/ | noun | A disadvantage or problem that makes something less attractive or enjoyable. | 弊端 | I believe that the potential benefits of this experience outweigh the drawbacks. |
| pursuits | /pərˈsuːts/ | /noun | /An activity that someone spends time doing, usually for enjoyment or to achieve something | /兴趣爱好 | /Students can discover their passions and make more informed decisions about their academic pursuits. |
| invaluable | /ɪnˈvæljuəbl/ | adjective | Extremely useful or important, especially because it cannot be replaced or measured in money. | 无价的 | My own gap year experience at a financial firm provided me with invaluable knowledge about economics. |
| aspirations | /ˌæspəˈreɪʃənz/ | noun | A strong desire to achieve something, such as success, power, or wealth. | 抱负 | I strongly advocate for students to consider taking a gap year as a means of reflecting on their aspirations. |
| well-rounded | /welˈraʊndɪd/ | /adjective | /Having a range of abilities or interests that are balanced and not limited to only one area | /全面发展的 | /Taking a gap year can help students make well-rounded choices for their futures. |
| major | /ˈmeɪdʒər/ | /noun | /The main subject that a student is studying at college or university | /主修课程 | /My gap year experience inspired me to major in economics at university. |
| advocate | /ˈædvəkeɪt/ | /verb | /To publicly support or recommend a particular cause or policy | /拥护,提倡 | /I strongly advocate for students to consider taking a gap year before starting their university education. |
2User Sample #2
From my perspective, I think I would side with Andrew. It is evident to me that making full use of a gap year is indispensable and has salient benefit...
Score28
User Sample #2
From my perspective, I think I would side with Andrew. It is evident to me that making full use of a gap year is indispensable and has salient benefit...
User Sample
From my perspective, I think I would side with Andrew. It is evident to me that making full use of a gap year is indispensable and has salient benefits. For one thing, there is no denying that students are curious and nervous about the future after graduation. After keeping studying for several years, students are willing to travel abroad in the gap year, which can serve as a break and enable students to explore the unknown world. Not only will they appreciate the beauty of the environment, but also they can broaden their horizon and foster respect for the diversity and inclusivity by enjoying the local customs and traditions. For instance, I went to Canada during my gap year, I visited various places, such as Niagara Falls. The fascinating rainbows shining in the mist and the fusion of the American and Canadian cultures all impressed me a lot. For another, just as what Andrew says, the gap year can provide students with opportunities to persue their goals and augement their abilities. It is a suitable time to do part-time jobs, which can help students to choose their favorite majors.
Evaluation Result
1. 子项得分
-
Relevance and Contribution to Discussion: 4.5
-
Clarity and Elaboration of Viewpoint: 4.0
-
Language Use and Grammar: 4.0
2. 预估分数
- 28
3. 任务完成度
总体来说,这篇文章较好地回答了问题,提出了支持休学一年的观点,并给出了一些具体的例子。但是,文章可以在以下方面进行改进:
-
在论述观点时,可以更具体地说明休学一年对学生的好处,如提高独立生活能力、锻炼沟通技巧等。
-
文章中提到的例子可以更加具体和详细,以便让读者更好地理解作者的观点。
示例1:在文章中可以添加关于工作经历对选择专业有帮助的具体例子,如:“例如,在休学期间从事金融行业的实习工作,可能会帮助学生发现他们对金融领域的兴趣和潜力。”
示例2:可以补充关于旅行如何拓宽视野和增进跨文化理解的例子,如:“在我去加拿大旅行期间,我还参观了当地的博物馆和历史遗址,这让我对加拿大历史和文化有了更深入的了解。”
4. 文章结构与组织
文章的结构和组织方面基本符合要求,包括引言、正文和结尾。但是,可以在以下方面进行改进:
-
在引言部分,可以简要介绍论述的两个观点,以便让读者对文章内容有一个大致的了解。
-
在正文部分,可以使用更明确的过渡词或短语来连接不同段落和观点。
示例1:在引言部分可以添加一句话来概括文章内容:“在本文中,我将阐述为什么休学一年对学生有益,并通过举例来支持我的观点。”
示例2:在正文部分,可以使用过渡词如“此外”、“然而”等来连接不同段落:“此外,在休学期间从事兼职工作还能帮助学生积累实践经验。”
5. 语法批改
From my perspective, I think I would side with Andrew. It is evident to me that making full use of a gap year is indispensable and has salient benefits.
For one thing, there is no denying that students are curious and nervous about the future after graduation. After keeping studying for several years, students are willing to travel abroad in the gap year, which can serve as a break and enable students to explore the unknown world. Not only will they appreciate the beauty of the environment, but also they can broaden their horizon and foster respect for the diversity and inclusivity by enjoying the local customs and traditions. For instance, I went to Canada during my gap year, I visited various places, such as Niagara Falls. The fascinating rainbows shining in the mist and the fusion of the American and Canadian cultures all impressed me a lot.
For another, just as what Andrew says, the gap year can provide students with opportunities to persuepursue(misspelling) their goals and augementaugment(misspelling) their abilities. It is a suitable time to do part-time jobs, which can help students to choose their favorite majors.
Title: 6 文章修订
In my opinion, taking a gap year offers more advantages than disadvantages for students, as it provides them with invaluable opportunities for personal growth and self-discovery. The benefits of a well-utilized gap year far outweigh any potential drawbacks.
Firstly, a gap year allows students to take a break from their studies and explore the world beyond the confines of their classrooms. By traveling or engaging in cultural exchanges, they can broaden their horizons and develop a deeper appreciation for diversity and inclusivity. For example, during my own gap year in Canada, I was captivated by the breathtaking beauty of Niagara Falls and the rich cultural blend of American and Canadian traditions. These experiences not only enriched my understanding of different cultures but also helped me grow as an individual.
Secondly, as Andrew mentioned, a gap year provides students with the opportunity to pursue their goals and enhance their skills. Engaging in part-time jobs or internships during this time can help them gain practical experience in various fields, enabling them to make more informed decisions about their future careers and academic pursuits. Furthermore, these experiences can also help students develop essential life skills such as time management, communication, and problem-solving abilities that will prove invaluable throughout their university years and beyond.
In conclusion, while some may argue that taking a gap year might not be financially beneficial due to rising tuition costs, I believe that the personal growth and development gained from such an experience are invaluable assets that cannot be measured solely in monetary terms. A well-planned gap year can provide students with unique opportunities for exploration, self-discovery, and skill-building that will ultimately contribute to their success in university and beyond. (284 words)
From In my perspective, I think I would side opinion, taking a gap year offers more advantages than disadvantages for students, as it provides them with Andrew. It is evident to me that making full use of a gap year is indispensable and has salient benefits. invaluable opportunities for personal growth and self-discovery (revised to clarify the writer's stance). The benefits of a well-utilized gap year far outweigh any potential drawbacks.
For one thing, there is no denying that Firstly, a gap year allows students are curious and nervous about the future after graduation. After keeping studying for several years, students are willing to travel abroad in the gap year, which can serve as to take a break and enable students to from their studies and explore the unknown world. Not only will they appreciate the beauty of the environment, but also world beyond the confines of their classrooms (revised for clarity). By traveling or engaging in cultural exchanges, they can broaden their horizon and foster respect for the horizons and develop a deeper appreciation for diversity and inclusivity by enjoying the local customs and traditions. (revised to improve flow). For instance, I went to Canada example, during my gap year, own gap year in Canada, I visited was captivated by the breathtaking beauty of Niagara Falls and the rich cultural blend of American and Canadian traditions (revised for clarity). These experiences not only enriched my understanding of different cultures but also helped me grow as an individual (revised to improve flow).
Secondly, as Andrew mentioned, a gap year provides students with the opportunity to pursue their goals and enhance their skills (revised for clarity). Engaging in part-time jobs or internships during this time can help them gain practical experience in various places, fields, enabling them to make more informed decisions about their future careers and academic pursuits (revised for clarity). Furthermore, these experiences can also help students develop essential life skills such as Niagara Falls. The fascinating rainbows shining in the mist and the fusion of the American and Canadian cultures all impressed me a lot. time management, communication, and problem-solving abilities that will prove invaluable throughout their university years and beyond (revised to improve flow).
For another, just as what Andrew says, the In conclusion, while some may argue that taking a gap year might not be financially beneficial due to rising tuition costs, I believe that the personal growth and development gained from such an experience are invaluable assets that cannot be measured solely in monetary terms (revised for clarity). A well-planned gap year can provide students with unique opportunities to persue their goals and augement their abilities. It is a suitable time to do part-time jobs, which can help students to choose their favorite majors.for exploration, self-discovery, and skill-building that will ultimately contribute to their success in university and beyond (revised to improve flow).
8 思维导图
Mindmap:
1. Introduction
- Gap year advantages
- Personal growth and self-discovery
2. Travel and cultural experiences
- Broaden horizons
- Appreciation for diversity and inclusivity
3. Pursue goals and enhance skills
- Part-time jobs or internships
- Informed decisions about future careers and academic pursuits
4. Develop essential life skills
- Time management, communication, problem-solving abilities
5. Conclusion
- Personal growth outweighs financial concerns
- Unique opportunities for exploration, self-discovery, and skill-building
9 关键词
| Word | Phonetic Symbol | Part of Speech | English definition | Simplified Chinese translation | Sample sentences |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| invaluable | /ɪnˈvæljuəbl/ | adjective | extremely useful; indispensable | 无价的,非常宝贵的 | The benefits of a well-utilized gap year are invaluable to personal growth. |
| horizons | /həˈraɪzənz/ | noun | the limit of a person's knowledge or experience | 视野,眼界 | A gap year can help students broaden their horizons by traveling or engaging in cultural exchanges. |
| appreciation | /əˌpriːʃiˈeɪʃən/ | noun | understanding of the importance or value of something | 欣赏,感激 | Students can develop a deeper appreciation for diversity and inclusivity during their gap year. |
| pursuits | /pərˈsuːts/ | noun | activities or hobbies that one engages in | 追求,兴趣爱好 | A gap year provides students with the opportunity to pursue their goals and enhance their skills. |
| practical | /ˈpræktɪkəl/ | adjective | concerned with actual use or practice | 实际的,实用的 | Engaging in part-time jobs during a gap year can help students gain practical experience. |
| essential | /ɪˈsenʃəl/ | adjective | absolutely necessary; extremely important | 必要的,非常重要的 | Time management, communication, and problem-solving abilities are essential life skills. |
| assets | /ˈæsets/ | noun | valuable qualities, skills, or resources | 资产,优点 | The personal growth and development gained from a gap year are invaluable assets. |
| exploration | /ekspləˈreɪʃən/ | noun | the action of traveling in or through an unfamiliar area to learn about it | 探险,探索 | A well-planned gap year can provide students with unique opportunities for exploration. |
| self-discovery | /self dɪˈskʌvəri/ | noun | -the process of gaining understanding of oneself | -自我发现 | -A gap year is an excellent time for self-discovery and personal growth. |
Opens the writing question list in the LingoLeap app, not this exact question. Practising needs a free account. AI scoring uses credits, except 3 free scores a day on Practice Test 1 (PQ26-1) questions.
How Academic Discussion Is Scored
The TOEFL Academic Discussion task is evaluated based on the official ETS scoring rubric. AI evaluation analyzes each response across multiple dimensions.
Relevance & Contribution
Does the response address the question and contribute meaningfully to the discussion?
Language Use
Grammar accuracy, vocabulary range, and sentence structure quality.
Development & Support
Are ideas well-developed with specific examples and clear reasoning?
Common Patterns Across Responses
Based on analysis of user submissions for this task, here are common patterns observed in student responses.
Many students provide clear opinions but lack specific supporting examples.
Strong responses directly reference the reading passage and other speakers' viewpoints.
Higher-scoring responses use varied sentence structures and academic vocabulary.
Time management is a key factor — responses that feel rushed tend to score lower on development.
Learning Tips
Read the prompt carefully and identify all parts of the question before writing.
Reference the reading passage and the other students' opinions in your response.
Use specific examples to support your main point — avoid generic statements.
Aim for 120-150 words. Longer responses are not always better; clarity and focus matter more.
Practice timed responses (10 minutes) to build fluency under exam conditions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the TOEFL Academic Discussion task?
How is the Academic Discussion task scored?
What are the user samples on this page?
How accurate is the AI evaluation?
How can I practice this Academic Discussion task?
How long should my Academic Discussion response be?
Related TOEFL Academic Discussion Tasks
All TOEFL Writing Samples
Browse all user-submitted TOEFL writing samples with AI evaluation
TOEFL Academic Discussion Guide
Learn strategies and tips for the Academic Discussion writing task
TOEFL Writing Guide
Complete guide to all TOEFL writing task types and scoring
TOEFL Speaking Guide
Master all TOEFL speaking tasks with expert strategies
TOEFL Reading Guide
Strategies for TOEFL reading comprehension tasks
TOEFL Listening Guide
Tips and practice for TOEFL listening comprehension
Related TOEFL Academic Discussion Tasks
Consumer Behavior
426 user-submitted samples available
Write A Post Responding To The Professors Question
1646 user-submitted samples available
Economics
325 user-submitted samples available
Academic Discussion
1031 user-submitted samples available
Environmental Science
501 user-submitted samples available
Sociology
1683 user-submitted samples available
Rooting for Your Goal Score Today!
With LingoLeap, an expert in English exams
Get to Your Dream Score Faster