TOEFL TPO 70 Writing Task 1 Sample: Summarize the points made in the lecture, being sure to explain how they cast doubt on the specific points made in the reading passage.

Historical user samples and AI evaluation results from an older TOEFL format.

288 archived user samples

Older TOEFL Format

This task is from a previous version of the TOEFL exam. The current TOEFL has a different structure. These archived samples remain available as a reference for practice.

Task Overview

Reading Passage

Palm oil, a liquid produced by palm trees and used for cooking and other purposes, has become very popular in recent years. As a result, the palm oil industry has had a dramatic impact on the economies and landscapes of countries in which it operates. When asked to make a recommendation about whether expanding palm oil production even more would be good or bad for the environment and the economy, many experts have stated that palm oil production has several positive and should be expanded. First, the experts point out that palm tree farming helps preserve the world's forests. Palm trees have a very high oil yield- - far higher than that of other crops. For this reason, farming palm trees requires less land than farming other crops to produce the same economic value. Since palm tree farms require relatively little (compared with many other crops), palm tree plantations require the clearing of smaller areas of forest than many other crops would, In other words, palm tree farms cause less deforestation and therefore have a lesser negative impact on the environment than other types of crops. Second, palm oil is sometimes used to produce biodiesel, a fuel for motor vehicles. Using biodiesel in vehicle engines creates fewer carbon emissions than using traditional fossil fuels does. Carbon emissions are known to contribute to climate change. Biodiesel from palm oil, when used as an alternative to fossil fuels, can help reduce this effect. Third, palm oil production helps reduce poverty among small-scale farmers. About 50 percent to 70 percent of land used for farming in palm-oil- producing countries is actually cleared by small-scale low-income family farmers. Growing palm trees is usually more profitable for such farmers than growing other crops, and it has in many cases helped improve the farmers' standard of living.

Question

Summarize the points made in the lecture, being sure to explain how they cast doubt on the specific points made in the reading passage.

User Samples & Evaluation Results

User Sample

The lecture casts doubt on the reading's claims about expending palm oil production, arguing that it may have numerous advantages, such as forests protection, less emissions, and high profit margin. Firstly, the reading passage maintains that the palm tree has a high oil yield, so it may occupy less land and preserve the forest. Conversely, the lecture contends that farmers clear more lands to produce palm oil because of the growing demand of this desirable oils. For example, an area of forest about 7000 square meters were cleared in one country. More lands were cultivated, which could not support that palm oil production contributes to the forest preservation. Secondly, the lecture challenges the reading's claims that it will create less carbon dioxide by producing biodiesel for motor vehicles. However, the lecture argues that the growth of palm generates more carbon emissions. Moreover, farmers clean lands by burning vegetations and plant material such as peat, which cause more air pollution. Lastly, while the reading passage asserts that small-scale farmers could get rid of poverty by producing palm oil, it is important to consider the control of profits. Large-scale farmers own the farm and control the profits of palm oil. In this situation, small-scale farmers could get little in return. Taking into account these counterarguments presented in the lecture, it becomes clear that there is insufficient evidence to support claims made in the reading passage regarding the benefits of producing palm oil.

Evaluation Result

1.子项得分 Task fulfillment: 4 Organization: 4 Coherence and Cohesion: 4 Language Use: 3

2.预估分数 Estimated Score: 25

3.任务完成度在任务完成度方面，文章成功总结了听力部分的观点，并对阅读部分的论点进行了质疑。然而，可以进一步改进的地方是在描述听力部分的论据时，需要更具体和详细地说明这些论据是如何质疑阅读材料中的观点的。此外，在引用听力中提到的例子时，也需要更准确地描述它们。

Example 1: Original: "For example, an area of forest about 7000 square meters were cleared in one country." Improved: "For example, in just one country, an area of forest equivalent to about 7,000 square meters is cleared every minute to make room for the palm trees."

Example 2: Original: "Moreover, farmers clean lands by burning vegetations and plant material such as peat, which cause more air pollution." Improved: "Moreover, farmers clear land for palm tree farming by burning the existing vegetation and plant material like peat, which releases significant amounts of carbon emissions into the atmosphere."

4.文章结构与组织 The essay has a clear structure with an introduction, body paragraphs addressing each point from the lecture, and a conclusion. However, there is room for improvement in terms of organization and transitions between ideas. The introduction could be more concise and clearly state that the lecture opposes the reading passage's claims. Additionally, transitions between paragraphs could be smoother to help guide the reader through the essay.

Example 1: Original: "The lecture casts doubt on the reading's claims about expending palm oil production, arguing that it may have numerous advantages, such as forests protection, less emissions, and high profit margin." Improved: "The lecture casts doubt on the reading's claims about expanding palm oil production by presenting counterarguments related to forest preservation, carbon emissions, and small-scale farmers' profits."

Example 2: Original: "Secondly, the lecture challenges the reading's claims that it will create less carbon dioxide by producing biodiesel for motor vehicles." Improved: "Secondly, although the reading passage suggests that producing biodiesel from palm oil results in fewer carbon emissions compared to traditional fuels, the lecture challenges this claim by highlighting additional emissions generated during palm tree farming."

5. 语法批改

The lecture casts doubt on the reading's claims about ~~expending~~expanding palm oil production, arguing that it may have numerous advantages, such as ~~forests~~forest protection, ~~less~~fewer emissions, and high profit ~~margin.~~margins. Firstly, the reading passage maintains that the palm tree has a high oil yield, so it may occupy less land and preserve ~~the forest.~~forests. Conversely, the lecture contends that farmers clear more ~~lands~~land to produce palm oil because of the growing demand ~~of this~~for these desirable oils. For example, an area of forest ~~about~~equivalent to 7000 square meters ~~were~~was cleared in one country. More ~~lands were~~land was cultivated, which could not support that palm oil production contributes to the forest preservation. Secondly, the lecture challenges the reading's claims that it will create ~~less~~fewer carbon dioxide by producing biodiesel for motor vehicles. However, the lecture argues that the growth of palm generates more carbon emissions. Moreover, farmers clean lands by burning ~~vegetations~~vegetation and plant material such as peat, which cause more air pollution. Lastly, while the reading passage asserts that small-scale farmers could ~~get rid of~~alleviate poverty by producing palm oil, it is important to consider the control of profits. Large-scale farmers own the ~~farm~~farms and control the profits of palm oil. In this situation, small-scale farmers could get little in return. Taking into account these counterarguments presented in the lecture, it becomes clear that there is insufficient evidence to support claims made in the reading passage regarding the benefits of producing palm oil.

Section title: 6.文章修订

The lecture casts doubt on the reading's claims about expanding palm oil production, arguing that it may have numerous advantages, such as forest protection, fewer emissions, and a high profit margin. Firstly, the reading passage maintains that the palm tree has a high oil yield, so it may occupy less land and preserve the forest. Conversely, the lecture contends that farmers clear more lands to produce palm oil because of the growing demand for these desirable oils. For example, an area of forest about 7000 square meters was cleared in one country. More lands were cultivated, which could not support that palm oil production contributes to forest preservation.

Secondly, the lecture challenges the reading's claims that it will create less carbon dioxide by producing biodiesel for motor vehicles. However, the lecture argues that the growth of palm generates more carbon emissions. Moreover, farmers clean lands by burning vegetation and plant material such as peat, which cause more air pollution.

Lastly, while the reading passage asserts that small-scale farmers could get rid of poverty by producing palm oil, it is important to consider control of profits. Large-scale farmers own the farm and control profits from palm oil production. In this situation, small-scale farmers could get little in return.

Taking into account these counterarguments presented in the lecture, it becomes clear that there is insufficient evidence to support claims made in the reading passage regarding the benefits of producing palm oil. (242 words)

Revised essay: Section title: 7.文章批改

The lecture casts doubt on the reading's claims about expanding (expending -> expanding) palm oil production, arguing that it may have numerous advantages, such as forest protection (forests ~~protection,~~ protection -> forest protection), fewer emissions (less ~~emissions, and~~ emissions -> fewer emissions), and a high profit margin. Firstly, the reading passage maintains that the palm tree has a high oil yield, so it may occupy less land and preserve the forest. Conversely, the lecture contends that farmers clear more lands to produce palm oil because of the growing demand for these desirable oils (of this desirable ~~oils.~~ oils -> for these desirable oils). For example, an area of forest about 7000 square meters ~~were~~ was cleared in one ~~country.~~ country (were cleared -> was cleared). More lands were cultivated, which could not support that palm oil production contributes to ~~the forest preservation.~~ forest preservation (the forest preservation -> forest preservation).

Secondly, the lecture challenges the reading's claims that it will create less carbon dioxide by producing biodiesel for motor vehicles. However, the lecture argues that the growth of palm generates more carbon emissions. Moreover, farmers clean lands by burning ~~vegetations~~ vegetation and plant material such as ~~peat,~~ peat (vegetations and plant material -> vegetation and plant material), which cause more air pollution.

Lastly, while the reading passage asserts that small-scale farmers could get rid of poverty by producing palm oil, it is important to consider ~~the~~ control of ~~profits.~~ profits (the control of profits -> control of profits). Large-scale farmers own the farm and control ~~the profits of palm oil.~~ profits from palm oil production (the profits of palm oil -> profits from palm oil production). In this situation, small-scale farmers could get little in return.

8. Mind Map


1. Introduction
   - Palm oil production
   - Reading vs. Lecture

2. Forest Preservation
   - Reading: High oil yield, less land needed
   - Lecture: Growing demand, more land cleared
       * Example: 7000 square meters of forest cleared

3. Carbon Emissions
   - Reading: Less CO2 with biodiesel production
   - Lecture: More emissions from palm growth
       * Burning vegetation and peat for land clearing

4. Profit Margin and Poverty Reduction
   - Reading: Small-scale farmers benefit financially
   - Lecture: Large-scale farmers control profits, little return for small-scale farmers

5. Conclusion
   - Insufficient evidence to support reading's claims about palm oil production benefits.

9. Keywords

Word	Phonetic Symbol	Part of Speech	English Definition	Simplified Chinese Translation	Sample Sentence
yield	/jiːld/	noun	the amount produced	产量	The high oil yield of palm trees allows them to occupy less land.
preserve	/prɪˈzɜːrv/	verb	to maintain in its original state	保护	The reading claims that palm oil production helps preserve forests by using less land.
emission	/ɪˈmɪʃən/	noun	the release of a substance into the atmosphere	排放物	The lecture argues that palm oil production creates more carbon emissions than it prevents.
biodiesel	/ˌbaɪoʊˈdiːzəl/	/noun	a fuel made from vegetable oil or animal fat	生物柴油	The reading suggests that biodiesel production from palm oil can reduce carbon dioxide emissions.
vegetation	/ˌvɛdʒɪˈteɪʃən/	noun	plant life, especially trees and shrubs	植被	Farmers clear lands by burning vegetation to make way for palm oil production.
peat	/piːt/	noun	/a brown soil-like material from decayed plants	泥炭	Burning peat during land clearing contributes to air pollution and carbon emissions.
profit margin	/ˈprɒfɪt ˈmɑːrdʒɪn/	noun	/the difference between revenue and cost	利润率	The reading claims that palm oil production has a high profit margin for small-scale farmers.
poverty	/ˈpɒvərti/	noun	/the state of being extremely poor	贫困	The reading suggests that palm oil production can help small-scale farmers escape poverty.
large-scale	/ˈlɑːrdʒ skeɪl/	/adjective	/involving many people or things	大规模的	Large-scale farmers control the profits from palm oil production, leaving little for small-scale farmers.
counterargument	/ˈkaʊntər ˌɑrɡjumənt/	noun	/an opposing argument	反驳论点	The lecture presents several counterarguments against the benefits of palm oil production claimed in the reading.