TOEFL TPO 58 Writing Task 1 Sample: Summarize the points made in the lecture, being sure to explain how they challenge the specific points made in the reading passage.

1.Sub Scores

• Task fulfillment: 4

• Organization: 4

• Coherence and Cohesion: 4

• Language Use: 3

2.Estimated Scores

• Estimated Score: 25

3.Task completeness The essay does a good job of summarizing the points made in the lecture and explaining how they challenge the specific points made in the reading passage. However, there is room for improvement in language use and clarity. To enhance your essay, consider refining your word choice and sentence structure to make your arguments more persuasive.

Example 1: Original sentence: "Therefor, one can not assume that going back to home is the only goal of Spartacus, and another goal can not be called nobility which makes Spartacus less appealing than the passage suggests." Improved sentence: "Therefore, it cannot be assumed that returning home was Spartacus' sole objective; his other goals were less noble, making him less appealing than the passage suggests."

Example 2: Original sentence: "This was becuase during that time, Europe went throught an anti-slavery movement which made people recreat the story of Spartacus to inpire people fighting againt slavery." Improved sentence: "This was because during that time, Europe experienced an anti-slavery movement which led people to recreate the story of Spartacus as a means to inspire those fighting against slavery."

4.Essay structure and organization The essay has a clear structure with an introduction, body paragraphs addressing each point from the lecture, and a conclusion. However, some transitions between ideas could be improved for better coherence and cohesion.

Example 1: Original transition: "Firstly... Secondly..." Improved transition: "Firstly... In addition..."

Example 2: Original transition: "Secondly... Finally..." Improved transition: "Furthermore... Lastly..."

By incorporating these suggestions into your essay writing practice, you will improve your task fulfillment, organization, coherence, and language use, ultimately leading to a higher score on the TOEFL iBT integrated writing Task 1.

5. Grammar

The reading passage suggests that Spartacus is an attractive hero for several reasons, while the speaker in the lecture displays a dinstinctdistinct(misspelling) perspective that they are not historically accurate.

Firstly, the passage claims that Spartacus's intention behind fighting against Rome is to return home. HoweverHowever,(Commas after conjunctive/linking adverbs in front of a new sentence.) the speaker rebuts this by asserting a fact that Spartacus and his men had had an opportunity to escape in the way, but instead they choose to march towards Rome to conquer. thisThis(Checks that a sentence starts with an uppercase letter) was because they wanted fame and properties. Therefor, one can not assume that going back to home is the only goal of Spartacus, and another goal can not be called nobilitynobility,(This rule identifies whether commas are missing in a sentence.) which makes Spartacus less appealing than the passage suggests.

Secondly, the passage put forwards that Spartacus' success of several battles in the first place demonstrates his excellent tanlenttalent(misspelling) for military. Conversely, the speaker points out that in the beginingbeginning(misspelling) of the fights, Rome did not take SpartausSpartans(misspelling) and his men seriously, so the soliderssoldiers(misspelling) that fought against them were also poor-trained and ill-equiped[No Replacement Word Found](misspelling). In a short time, Spartacus was defeated quickly when Rome sent regular solders coming. Thereby, it does not nessassrily[No Replacement Word Found](misspelling) mean that Spartacus was a remarkable military genius.

Finally, the passage mentions that Spartacus refused Rome's offer to be a senator and freed his men, which intended toin(This rule identifies wrong preposition usage.) exchange for his stopping fighting. Nevertheless, the speaker rufutesrefutes(misspelling) this by highlighting this was story made by European people in 18 centrycentury(misspelling). This was becuasebecause(misspelling) during that time, Europe went throught anthrough tan(misspelling) anti-slavery movement which made people recreatretreat(misspelling) the story of Spartacus to inpireinspire(misspelling) people fighting againtagainst(misspelling) slavery. Consequently, we can not take Spartacus as a pinoorpinier(misspelling) of anti-slavery.

Section Title: 6. Revised Essay

The reading passage suggests that Spartacus is an attractive hero for several reasons, while the speaker in the lecture presents a distinct perspective, arguing that these reasons are not historically accurate.

Firstly, the passage claims that Spartacus's intention behind fighting against Rome was to return home. However, the speaker rebuts this by asserting that Spartacus and his men had an opportunity to escape along the way but chose instead to march towards Rome to conquer it. This decision was driven by their desire for fame and wealth. Therefore, one cannot assume that returning home was their only goal, and this additional motivation makes Spartacus less appealing than the passage suggests.

Secondly, the passage puts forward the idea that Spartacus' initial success in several battles demonstrates his exceptional military talent. Conversely, the speaker points out that at the beginning of these fights, Rome did not take Spartacus and his men seriously; as a result, they faced poorly-trained and ill-equipped soldiers. In a short time, Spartacus was defeated quickly when Rome sent its regular soldiers into battle. Thereby, it does not necessarily mean that Spartacus was a remarkable military genius.

Finally, the passage mentions that Spartacus refused Rome's offer to become a senator and free his men in exchange for stopping his fight against them. Nevertheless, the speaker refutes this by highlighting that this story was created by European people in the 18th century during an anti-slavery movement. This movement led people to recreate the story of Spartacus as an inspirational figure fighting against slavery. Consequently, we cannot consider Spartacus as a pioneer of anti-slavery based on this information alone. (273 words)

The reading passage suggests that Spartacus is an attractive hero for several reasons, while the speaker in the lecture displays a dinstinct perspective that they presents a distinct (changed "dinstinct" to "distinct" for correct spelling) perspective, arguing that these reasons are not historically accurate.

Firstly, the passage claims that Spartacus's intention behind fighting against Rome is was to return home. However However, the speaker rebuts this by asserting a fact that Spartacus and his men had had an opportunity to escape in the way, along the way but chose instead they choose to march towards Rome to conquer. this was because they wanted conquer it. This decision was driven by their desire for fame and properties. Therefor, wealth. Therefore (changed "Therefor" to "Therefore" for correct spelling), one can not cannot assume that going back to returning home is the was their only goal of Spartacus, and another goal can not be called nobility which goal, and this additional motivation makes Spartacus less appealing than the passage suggests.

Secondly, the passage put forwards puts forward the idea that Spartacus' initial success of in several battles in the first place demonstrates his excellent tanlent for military. exceptional military talent. Conversely, the speaker points out that in the begining at the beginning of the these fights, Rome did not take Spartaus Spartacus and his men seriously, so the soliders that fought against them were also poor-trained and ill-equiped. seriously; as a result, they faced poorly-trained and ill-equipped soldiers. In a short time, Spartacus was defeated quickly when Rome sent its regular solders coming. Thereby, soldiers into battle. Thereby (added comma), it does not nessassrily necessarily mean that Spartacus was a remarkable military genius.

Finally, the passage mentions that Spartacus refused Rome's offer to be become a senator and freed his men, which intended to free his men in exchange for his stopping fighting. Nevertheless, his fight against them. Nevertheless (changed "rufutes" to "refutes" for correct spelling), the speaker rufutes refutes this by highlighting this was that this story made was created by European people in 18 centry. This was becuase the 18th century during that time, Europe went throught an anti-slavery movement. This movement which made led people recreat to recreate the story of Spartacus to inpire people as an inspirational figure fighting againt against slavery. Consequently, Consequently (added comma), we can not take cannot consider Spartacus as a pinoor pioneer of anti-slavery.anti-slavery based on this information alone.

---

8. Mind Map

Mind Map:

1. Introduction
   - Reading passage: Spartacus as an attractive hero
   - Lecture: Contradictory historical accuracy

2. Intention to return home
   - Passage: Main goal was to return home
   - Lecture: Desire for fame and wealth, not just returning home

3. Exceptional military talent
   - Passage: Successful in several battles, demonstrating talent
   - Lecture: Rome didn't take them seriously initially, faced weak soldiers

4. Refusal of senatorship and freedom for men
   - Passage: Rejected Rome's offer, fought against slavery
   - Lecture: Story created during 18th-century anti-slavery movement, not historically accurate

5. Conclusion
   - Spartacus' heroism not as clear-cut as reading passage suggests due to lecture's points on historical accuracy.

9. Key Words